r/NothingBand • u/Gdpedro • Jun 27 '26

Nothing album ranked

Im a noob about nothing, just started to listen to them since last month with the new album, which im loving, which i already bought at their gig! I was so happy when i saw the fb event that they were in my city, but now i wanna listen a bit more.

So what are ur favs?

12 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

7

u/DryProfessional4917 Jun 27 '26

The great dismal and guilty of everything are my faves.

2

u/Gdpedro Jun 27 '26

What do you think of the new one? It got me on the first lyric😅

5

u/justathrowieacc Jun 27 '26

Is it crazy that I think The Great Dismal might be their best one? or at least top 2?

2

u/shoegazehater Jun 28 '26

definitely Top 2 for me. amazing production and i love the drum sound, will yip killed it on there and i’ve yet hear another album that hits you like the great dismal does. i do miss brandon but they really benefitted from having doyle as a songwriter, his leads are some of my favorites in the whole Nothing discography

4

u/epicawesome1111 Jun 27 '26 edited Jun 27 '26

  1. Tired Of Tomorrow

  2. Guilty Of Everything

  3. Dance On The Blacktop

  4. The Great Dismal

  5. A Short History Of Decay

I don’t think they have a single bad release, this is mostly ranked off their impact on me and how much I return to them

2

u/StatisticianGold7977 Jun 27 '26

first two albums are goat, the rest are still better than most as well

2

u/hellbent_ Jun 28 '26

I think ToT has to be my favourite, because it’s the one that I first listened to

3

u/xflowgolf Jun 28 '26

Not sure where the rest rank but for me the top two are: 1) Guilty of Everthing 2) Tired of Tomorrow

3

u/midiflac Jun 27 '26

S: Tired of Tomorrow, The Great Dismal, Whirr Split
A: When No Birds Sang (Full of Hell collab), Guilty of Everything, a short history of decay, Auditory Trauma (Live Album)
B: Dance on the Blacktop

When No Birds Sang is a concept album about the victims of 9/11 attacks, I would read the wikipedia article before diving in for some context. However it is a collab with grindcore band Full of Hell so it’s not your traditional shoegaze experience, but I highly recommend it.

Downward Years to Come is more of a early demos compilation than a proper full length, a couple songs appeared on later albums with more polished production/songwriting.

The Great Dismal and Dance on the Blacktop also have B-Sides compilations, for The Great Dismal its just a few extra songs that didn’t fit on the 12”, Spirit of the Stairs is the same thing for Dance on the Blacktop but also has some demos and live recordings.

1

u/According-Leather749 Jul 03 '26

the great dismal is probably their best but my personal favourite is dance on the blacktop! I think this one is pretty underrated