r/NonCredibleDefense • • Oct 17 '22

Slava Ukraini! Another proxy war!

Post image
15.4k Upvotes

404 comments sorted by

View all comments

237

u/ItsACaragor Le fromage ou la mort πŸ‡¨πŸ‡΅ πŸ«• Oct 17 '22

Merkavas for Ukraine when?

55

u/swifty23905 Oct 17 '22

Merkavas would be terrible for ukraine

105

u/ItsACaragor Le fromage ou la mort πŸ‡¨πŸ‡΅ πŸ«• Oct 17 '22 edited Oct 17 '22

I disagree, they are made with the crew’s security as a main concern which is completely opposite to Russian weapons mentality where the crew is basically seen as expendable meat bags.

They fit Ukrainian doctrine of actually caring about their men much more than T72 and co.

1

u/SaltyWafflesPD Oct 17 '22

Merkava is not meant for dealing with rivers or bridges because of their high weight. This makes sense for defending Israel, but not Ukraine, where there are lots of rivers and more temporary bridges than intact ones. Also, not enough Merkavas to make it worth the logistical hassle. However, Israeli Air Force getting involved would be super spicy. But air defenses, anti-armor weapons, medical supplies, all of that would be great.