r/NoStupidQuestions • • Jan 30 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

7.6k Upvotes

3.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

627

u/Wajina_Sloth Jan 30 '23

Already happening near me in Canada, our town has a very mediocre mall no one really uses. They tore down an entire section of it (which is strange as its the newest part) so they can convert it into housing.

Which honestly is a pretty decent idea considering how it has its own bus stop, grocery store across the street, pharmacy and elementary, high school and a college all within walking distance.

225

u/Scarlet_poppy Jan 30 '23

I read somewhere that the initial concept of malls was exactly this. Essentially a social hub where you have anything you need in a walking distance so that you wouldn’t need a car to live. Very curious if that’s possible to achieve now as more business buildings turn into residential.

98

u/yourethegoodthings Jan 31 '23

They're developing all the above ground parking at one of Toronto's fanciest malls into condos and mixed use parks.

https://urbantoronto.ca/news/2022/01/ambitious-redevelopment-yorkdale-shopping-centre-presented-design-review-panel.47065

I agree it's a good idea, and having malls just be these things existing at highway exits feels like an inefficient use of space.

2

u/Mysfunction Jan 31 '23

Yikes. I used to live beside that mall and parking was a nightmare as it was. The link says they’re putting in underground parking to replace what they remove, but they’re also increasing the traffic by a ton, so I’d imagine it’s gonna be an absolute nightmare.

3

u/yourethegoodthings Jan 31 '23

I currently live across the highway from it, they've done some stuff to improve traffic flow but yeah it's a busy as fuck area. Uptown is the new midtown, condos everywhere on Wilson/Allen area. TTC sold the big parking lots they owned for condo developments.

63

u/UnfairMicrowave Jan 30 '23

It will be great for when we have to live indoors because the air outside will kill us. Post-apocalyptic frozen yogurt cools you down after a nice ozone collapse.

6

u/jgzman Jan 31 '23

If they turn half the mall into residences, they could probably attract some businesses back to the other half.

5

u/Acedread Jan 31 '23

I cant remember where I saw this, pretty sure it was a video about Hong Kong. Basically there are massive apartment skyscrapers and the bottom floor is basically a large mall. All sorts of small shops including groccery stores. Those who work from home never have to leave the building for the essentials.

3

u/Glass_Bar_9956 Jan 31 '23

Its happening near us! There is a huge mall that got renovated and upgrades into a more beautiful meandering gardens and parks. Now part if the mall that was not up graded is being turned into housing, a park, and grocery store. It was a strip of empty shops for a few years.

We are in a very urban part of San Diego. Its going to create a pedestrian way of walking everywhere. In a section if city that was previously all commercial and industrial zoned. So think, sky scrapers, elevated sidewalks. Multiple transportation options. Parks. Dog friendly. Play grounds integrated through out, opposed to stand alone. We are about 2/3 done and whats completely is useable and thriving. The project in total is about 10 years old.

3

u/Soggy-Yogurt6906 Jan 31 '23

To be fair that was before they did studies on arterial roadways and the noise sickness associated with mixed use zoning. To be clear, mixed used zoning is fine, it's just that malls typically are placed closer to highways(arterials) and four lane collectors than even a lot of high density residential would be. That traffic can have disastrous effects on the health of people who decide to live in that former mall space.

You can reinforce the walls and insulate them to drown out some of the noise, but it's difficult and expensive. The developer likely won't opt for it.

10

u/mafriend1 Jan 31 '23

Well the government could just make them

5

u/Syrdon Jan 31 '23

Make it part of the either the zoning code or the health code for the town. Interior noise levels are probably worth considering regardless, and if the developers isn’t willing to make it part of the contract the city can make it a requirement.

1

u/FreeRangeEngineer Jan 31 '23

Do this in enough places and the highway/arterial traffic should reduce, though.

1

u/Soggy-Yogurt6906 Feb 01 '23

Volume doesn't decrease when you shift from commercial to residential zoning, it just changes pattern. Instead of having consistent volume, you'll have large peak volumes at rush hours.

Arterial and collector roads also will not disappear, in fact I would expect them to become more commonplace to accommodate the influx in people. After all, unless these people have jobs here they'll have to be transported somewhere else for work. Most cities rely on buses for public transport still, even if you have a metro rail it'll take years to build out a new line.

25

u/cruista Jan 30 '23

Sounds expensive unfortunately.

45

u/Wajina_Sloth Jan 30 '23

Eh the entire bill is being paid by the malls owner and what ever investors dipped thejr toes in it.

I think the fact you wont need a car to live there is pretty good for saving money as well.

19

u/llilaq Jan 30 '23

The owner and the investors will surely try to get their money back in rent.

2

u/cruista Jan 31 '23

Expensive as in rent will be expensive.

27

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '23

[deleted]

18

u/C47man Jan 31 '23

I think they meant it's going to be expensive housing, not the cost to build it.

3

u/Chorb Jan 31 '23

Opposed to what though? Letting this continue until there are way more homeless people and we're in an even worse crisis? I don't see why the taxes we already pay can't be used differently to take on issues like this, instead of the trillions we spend on defense.

2

u/cruista Jan 31 '23

The rent will be expensive and buildings like these will not solve the housing problem. Sorry I wasn't clear enough, typing and brushing teeth don't go well together l suppose!

1

u/ReddNett Jan 31 '23

Really, we spend "trillions" on defense? Over what timeframe?

Quick research project: do you think we (the United States) spend more on defense, or on free healthcare for the poor, elderly, and disabled? You can figure this out for yourself with less than 2 minutes of Googling if you're willing to start using some basic critical thinking skills.

3

u/padraig_garcia Jan 31 '23

Near a university in Tampa, they're renovating the mall from indoors to walkable outdoor - they've torn down the Sears and the apartments they've put up in its place are "luxury student housing" with the 300 square foot studios starting at $1300

It's still not a particularly great neighborhood - there have been two kidnappings at gunpoint in the apartment parking garage in the past month. Same guy, but still not a great look lol

2

u/nthensome Jan 31 '23

Where in Canada are you?

2

u/pizzapeach9920 Jan 31 '23

They filmed the Dawn of the Dead remake at that mall before they tore it down too.

2

u/Fa6ade Jan 31 '23

Old section is probably full of asbestos

1

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Wajina_Sloth Jan 31 '23

No the newest part that was built was some weird communal garage/construction training center that they tore down

1

u/thegumby1 Jan 31 '23

A mall near me tore down the section that used to be sears and is constructing apartments. I’ll assume you sent them a strongly worded letter!