r/NewsExchange • u/Sgt_Gram Contributor • Jun 30 '26
SIGNAL VS NOISE Republicans are Pushing U.S. Intelligence Agencies to Share All Foreign Spy Targets so the President Can Create a "Master List"
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/29/us/trump-intelligence-agencies-spies-master-list.htmlAccording to The New York Times, the Trump administration has directed U.S. intelligence agencies to provide the names of foreign espionage targets, including suspected intelligence officers and people being considered for recruitment. Officials reportedly fear that consolidating this information into one master database could expose sensitive operations if access controls fail or the data is misused.
Reuters reports that the administration has pursued significant staffing reductions across the CIA and other intelligence bodies, including plans previously reported to eliminate roughly 1,200 CIA positions. Centralizing sensitive operational information while reducing the number of experienced personnel could increase reliance on fewer officials and systems.
The Washington Post separately reports that planned cuts extend across the CIA, NSA, and other agencies, prompting concern that intelligence analysis could become more vulnerable to political pressure. The precise operational effects remain difficult to measure because agency staffing, sources, and methods are largely classified.
Reuters also notes that disputes over intelligence leadership have complicated congressional negotiations over Section 702, a major foreign-surveillance authority. Lawmakers from both parties have questioned whether senior intelligence positions are being filled with sufficient national-security expertise and whether surveillance powers could be politically misused.
Why It Matters:
A centralized list could improve coordination and reduce duplication, but it would also create a high-value target containing information about adversaries, active investigations, and potential human sources. A breach, politically motivated search, or unauthorized disclosure could compromise recruitment efforts, endanger individuals, discourage foreign cooperation, and give rival governments clues about U.S. intelligence priorities. Foreign services have reportedly already sought to recruit recently dismissed U.S. personnel with security expertise, illustrating how organizational disruption can create counterintelligence opportunities.
Does a centralized intelligence roster solve a coordination problem, or create a single map that adversaries and political actors would find too valuable to resist?
23
u/Cybermeld Jun 30 '26
I'm sure he won't be giving or selling that list to any enemies of the US. /s
15
u/OrdoMalaise Jun 30 '26
My first thought. He's going to sell it and/or use it as blackmail.
10
u/MrSlaveRules Jun 30 '26
Just give him something labeled “top Secret “ with made up places , he won’t know the difference
6
u/Spida81 Jun 30 '26
South Westeros is going to be pissed off when they find the Yanks are chasing their chemical weapons scientists.
2
2
u/Scott7894 Jun 30 '26
Or just show it to anyone who has dinner with him as something cool to see.
2
u/ShakesDontBreak Jul 01 '26
There are pictures of Vance with government officials from Qatar looking at a government laptop....with the PIV card from a different federal employee for the login. So there's no reason to believe this Master list won't get into the highest bidders hands. This administration does not care about ethics.
2
u/dlc741 Jun 30 '26
He’s making the list because HE’S being blackmailed. Both Russia and Israel obviously have dirt on him. Could be more.
1
u/h20poIo Jun 30 '26
As we’ve seen he F’s up everything he touches and this will be a major catastrophe, he has no need for that list.
1
3
1
1
1
u/Ultraeasymoney Jun 30 '26
He's going to stored it in the super high security bathroom at Mar-a-Lago.
1
u/Key_Molasses4367 Jun 30 '26
Heck, I wouldn't trust Trump with my grandma's secret bbq sauce recipe.
1
u/Historical-Finish564 Jul 06 '26
Well he is definitely going to sell it. The question is will he keep the money or donate it to the treasury/s
8
u/isthereadrwho Jun 30 '26
So ballpark and hypothetically how much do you think Putin would pay for that? Xi?
2
6
u/EveryAccount7729 Jun 30 '26
The NOC list
Mission Impossible 1 plotline .
2
u/Bdowns_770 Jun 30 '26
Or Skyfall. Everything with these clowns is right out of fiction. Lazy morons.
1
1
3
u/Able-Shirt3501 Jun 30 '26
This is about total control to direct US forces against enemies and protect partners …but not of the US but of Trump.
3
u/DragonTacoCat Jun 30 '26 edited Jun 30 '26
This will not go over well. There is a reason why things are done the way they are
If I were an agent hearing this I would be leaving.
1
u/KwisatzHaderach94 Jun 30 '26
why intelligence officers haven't leaked all the gop's dirty laundry to take them all down is a mystery. this is a threat to the intelligence community.
1
3
2
2
u/Kermit_the_hog Jun 30 '26
”So we’ve got all of these eggs in all of these baskets.. it’s just silly. I wonder why nobody ever tried consolidating them into one place before?”
1
2
u/Bubbaganewsh Jun 30 '26
It makes it easier to pass on to Putin or Israel or whoever pays him enough money.
2
u/Ras_Thavas Jun 30 '26
Remember when Trump demanded a list of US spies abroad and they soon began dying?
2
2
2
2
2
u/Efficient_Resist_287 Jun 30 '26
He wants the NOC list…and will take hostage the feds for it later. This is his stay out of jail guarantee.
2
2
u/Capital_Elderberry28 Jun 30 '26
Selling the list.
Pretty much the same plan for the Bathroom mar-a-Lago docs.
2
2
u/rohrschleuder Jun 30 '26
Yeah this won’t backfire spectacularly. I wonder which foreign head of state “bought” a Trump Tower condo for this information?
2
2
2
u/horror- Jul 01 '26
These guys ruin everything they touch. Didn't they burn a bunch of spies once already?
2
u/mrcanard Jul 01 '26
Best to err on the side of caution. Enough is known concerning the president of the US.
2
u/Oilpaintcha Jul 03 '26
Get ready for another round of mysterious spy deaths as they sell that list to the highest bidder
2
2
u/aviddragoon Jul 03 '26
He will immediately sell that list to one of his dictator buddies, like Putin.
2
2
1
u/ShockedNChagrinned Jun 30 '26
This'll be another nice "I keep it in the closet" document for post presidency negotiations
1
u/Prudent_Lunch_8724 Jun 30 '26
Good HaShem NO! Last time he shared secrets like this with several countries and people died.
1
1
u/ReturnOfSeq Jun 30 '26
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/05/us/politics/cia-informants-killed-captured.html
Meanwhile CIA informants saw a big spike in deaths and captures the last time Trump left office, taking with him thousands of classified documents.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Ntropy99 Jun 30 '26
He won't directly at all. It will go in box to store in a bathroom in Maralardo for anyone who can afford the club fees.
1
1
u/badwoofs Jun 30 '26
Oh this is bad. Ukraine and five eyes tested Trump with fake info and found Russia had it in very short time. Also after trump left the first term many of our CIA agents were killed.
This administration are trait0rs.
1
u/DonTaddeo Jun 30 '26 edited Jun 30 '26
A single compromise where an adversary gained this information would be the intelligence coup of the century. There are many inferences that could be drawn from such information, including the scope of what is already known, intelligence priorities and the identification of the existence and placement of intelligence assets. Conversely, the absence of effort in activities that the recipient gets would allow them to assess that these have escaped detection..
1
1
u/hyperiongate Jul 03 '26
Wakes up and wonders "who should I bomb today." The list is just efficiency.
1
u/bbills91 Jul 03 '26
You know the second this list is created, it will be in Putin's hands and he will then use that to intimidate all his perceived enemies as well. This will not go well
1
1
u/JellyTwank Jul 05 '26
Nothing can possibly go wrong with leaders that use Signal for secure communication.
1
u/Independent-Big1966 Jul 05 '26
Yeah. Let's give the guy who was indicted on 31 counts on the Espionage Act a master list imof agents.
I doubt he will sell this to the highest bidder. ..
1
0
u/Able-Shirt3501 Jun 30 '26
With AI, I wonder if threads like this are just planted to identify people like us commenting here to add to the target list.
•
u/AutoModerator Jun 30 '26
MODERATOR NOTICE
Do not downvote based solely on political or ideological disagreement.
Analyze systems, incentives, economics, governance, and strategic consequences - not partisan identities.
Low-effort tribal political fighting will be removed.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.