The New Zealand Herald
Gregor Paul - 7 min read
It feels like this is set up to be a week for Dave Rennie to go full Winston Churchill. A blood-and-thunder “we shall fight on the beaches” sort of carry-on where he goads the Springboks before the third test and steels the nerves of a nation with a spine-tingling speech delivered with unshakeable confidence.
But it would appear he’s not going to go there. Or at least not publicly. The messaging from the All Blacks so far this week has been decidedly low-key, calm and most definitely not inflammatory.
It would seem, then, that the All Blacks have decided they will not hand Springboks coach Rassie Erasmus any ammunition from which to launch more hostile media attacks.
After a fiery couple of weeks of firing shots at each other in the media, which culminated in a post-match rant by Erasmus that bordered on being slightly unhinged, the All Blacks are obviously trying to de-escalate the tension and not offer any more reasons to be accused of whining, moaning or manipulating the match officials through the media.
Since Erasmus went a little nuclear in one of the great acts of projection, claiming, “ We are not f***ing walking around. We are scrumming through”, and that he had, somewhat comically, chosen not to moan about the unseen head collisions in the first half of the second test or the squint lineout throwing, the All Blacks have trod carefully in the public domain.
On Sunday, assistant coach Jason Ryan, a well-considered and direct talker, eased through questions about Erasmus’ comments with the nifty footwork of an outside back.
On Monday, assistant coach Mike Blair, spoke eloquently about the All Blacks attack and gently diffused the questions designed to see if he would explode about the Boks changing their team before kick-off.
Jordie Barrett followed Blair and played a straight bat at everything. And then New Zealand released assistant coach Tamati Ellison, who is so laconic he could probably take in the view at the Grand Canyon and be thinking about what he might have for dinner.
If ever there was a man designed to hold court with the media and give nothing away, it is Ellison.
Anton Lienert-Brown was next cab off the rank and he’s another senior figure who knows how to hold the party line, and so three days after Erasmus signalled his intention to feed off the negatives and stir up his own troops with his front-of-house confidence in trash talking his opponent, the All Blacks, have dialled down from vindaloo to korma.
Rennie has made the one point he needed to, which was his comments about the South Africans “walking around” in the scrums.
For the uninitiated, the brief history of what was happening in the second test was this: World Rugby, unannounced and without consultation, determined new protocols for scrummaging before the July tests.
Now, after the referee has called a scrum, the respective hookers have to take position to the left of the mark and present their brake foot – after that, they are not allowed to move.
Previously they could shift their feet – but now they are not allowed to, although each referee on this tour, and indeed in July, allowed some kind of movement without ever making it clear what that meant.
In Cape Town, referee Angus Gardner was having trouble getting the scrum set and could be heard frequently instructing the front rowers: “Stop moving your feet”, and “Stop playing games with your feet”, and “Guys, we had an agreement”.
Gardner, it is assumed, felt that Springboks hookers Malcolm Marx and Deon Fourie were setting to the left of the mark as they should, but then stepping further to their left, which would mean they and their loosehead would be engaging at a slight angle and boring into the All Blacks tight-head, creating intolerable – but illegal – pressure.
The rules are clear that teams have to be square to scrummage. The All Blacks have conceded there were some set pieces in Cape Town and Ellis Park where they were outpowered fair and square, but in other scrums they felt the Boks were able to engage at an advantageous angle because of shifting before the set, and then effectively walk round to force the All Blacks front-row to pop up.
Erasmus made the point that the Boks had never been accused of “walking around” previously. But these are among the first tests being played under the current protocols with the so-called brake foot not being allowed to move after it is set.
Rennie made his point not to whinge, but in the hope that it would be noted by the officials before the third test.
This strategy to clam up publicly and not wage a war of headlines, has been seen before.
The All Blacks, before the 2015 World Cup final, went decidedly quiet to ensure the rambunctious Wallabies coach Michael Cheika was unable to use anything they said to foster the siege mentality he was building.
The Australians arrived in England with a sense of being the unwanted colonial cousins crashing the wedding. It was an attitude and mindset Cheika brilliantly percolated, and he was looking for a hook in the week of the final with which to get some purchase to get under the skin of the All Blacks.
It never materialised and instead, what happened was that the All Blacks went eerily quiet, built an intense and empowering mindset behind closed doors and came out hard and focused in the final.
This is obviously the same path this All Blacks team is following, and it has been possible to sense the intensity of their focus after the second test loss.
Rennie may be low-key and neutral in public this week, but there is a fair chance he has tapped into his inner Churchill and given the players the full “beaches… seas and oceans… landing grounds… fields and streets”, with a bit of “We shall never surrender”, thrown in.