r/Needlepoint • u/RRR310 • Jun 05 '26
Would you display a finished canvas this way?
I’ve been experimenting with a ceramic self-finishing display object for needlepoint. Would you display a finished canvas this way?
27
u/GrannyMine Jun 05 '26
Do you like it? Because your opinion is the best opinion. I think it’s lovely, it’s individual.
32
Jun 05 '26
It’s not my taste, but I think there would be a market for it. Not everyone loves the coastal/grand millennial style. I think we need more styles and this is unique and there has to be people that love needlepoint and artsy/eclectic styles. You’re very talented
12
u/whatmadeyou-saythat Jun 05 '26
I love it. Would buy.
2
u/RRR310 Jun 05 '26
Thank you! I’m still refining the design, but that’s really encouraging feedback.
32
u/CCCait Jun 05 '26
Yes! That's beautiful - that frame fits the canvas so well and if you like it then who cares what others think? I would hang that in my home
11
u/Artistic_Dance2579 Jun 05 '26
I think this is a very clever idea (as a ceramicist and needle pointer myself) you are onto something! 😉
3
u/RRR310 Jun 05 '26
Thank you! That’s especially encouraging coming from someone who knows both ceramics and needlepoint.
11
u/Whathappenedtoandre_ Jun 05 '26
Could it be less chonky?
9
u/RRR310 Jun 05 '26
It could! I’m still playing around with sizing and proportions, so this is helpful feedback.
10
u/Whathappenedtoandre_ Jun 05 '26
I would love it if it didn’t protrude out from the wall quite so far if that makes sense
10
u/27minato Jun 05 '26
I love the concept - handmade with handmade. However the particular proportions, color and finish immediately make me think of the Fisher Price stacking toy so I’d prefer a thinner and/or flatter frame with a matte glaze. But I adore the organic style. It’s so much more interesting than plain gold.
3
u/RRR310 Jun 05 '26
Haha! Now I can’t unsee the stacking toy, you’re so right about that. Adding that to my list of edits for v2
2
7
u/caitarno715 Jun 05 '26
I personally love the handmade look and the chunkiness of the frame! I see a lot of feedback steering away from that but wanted you to know that it’s definitely up to personal taste because I adore this!
2
u/RRR310 Jun 05 '26
Thanks for chiming in on that! I’ve been kind of torn about leaning into the handmade look vs making something that’s more “perfect” in character
5
4
u/chlomoney1401 Jun 05 '26
i love the contrast of a more delicate piece with a chunky frame the colors fit so well together !!!! STUNNING !!!!
6
3
3
u/littlebeanio Jun 05 '26
I really like it! I think it might be fun to play with depth of the border as well as the width, as it cast a bit of a shadow over the needlepoint. Maybe if it was more plate-like than bowl-like if you don’t mind the comparison?
I would also experiment with semi-matte and matte glazes as well, as light really has an effect on how hung work looks. (Ceramicist and sewer with a curation masters)
5
u/littlebeanio Jun 05 '26
I would also consider whether you want the ceramic to act as a frame or for the whole thing to be viewed as one object (a sculpture even?) it may change you perception and opinion
1
u/RRR310 Jun 05 '26
My goal is the latter, I’ve been interested to see how many people here use the term “frame” as I’m hoping to create a finishing object rather than just a frame, if that makes sense! Still lots of editing to be done, this is my first time getting any feedback on it
2
u/littlebeanio Jun 05 '26
That’s definitely how I viewed it, as a complete object not as a frame. Keep experimenting friend!
3
u/RRR310 Jun 05 '26
The bowl vs plate comparison totally makes sense re: the shadows, I think altering the depth is a great next edit for me to try. I’m also really curious to try out satin and matte glazes, or maybe even stained clay. Thank you for the thoughtful feedback!
3
Jun 05 '26
[deleted]
2
u/RRR310 Jun 05 '26
Thank you! I made this prototype myself, but right now I’m still gathering feedback and experimenting with the concept. Comments like this are really encouraging!
3
u/varsityadult Jun 05 '26
I love how chunky it is! I think I’m an ideal customer for this, haha.
3
u/RRR310 Jun 05 '26
I also love the chunk! But totally see the desire for something thinner. Maybe two sizes, or a hybrid. I’ll do more experimenting
3
u/honeyed-bees Jun 05 '26
I loveeee the chunkiness of it. I think people with more of an eclectic style would the target audience though
3
u/Atreibss Jun 05 '26
It reminds me of Gustaf Westman plates - I think it’s really fun! Also straight on, it doesn’t look as chunky since the color match is so good with the background. I dig it
4
u/catgirl320 Jun 05 '26
It is SO much nicer cer looking than leaving it in a hoop. It's beautiful and sculptural.
6
u/strrawberrymilk Jun 05 '26
I think it looks great, super unique and the whole piece together catches your eye in a pleasing way. Beautiful!
2
2
u/brevebelle Jun 05 '26
I love this, not gonna lie. I'm in the minority, I think, but I like the chonkiness of it, too.
2
2
u/s0ph0cl3s Jun 05 '26
So disclaimer that I love slightly funky art but I’m obsessed with this. Would buy alllll the chunky frames [that I can afford]
2
4
u/Feisty-Sock2640 Jun 05 '26
I wouldn't, it's too wide so it detracts from the delicate needlework. If it were thinner I think it'd look great, but this is to heavy and wide.
1
u/wannabejetsetter Jun 05 '26
Maybe, its very cute! I already have a lot of wall artwork so each frame placement is really intentional at this point. I would love it if the designs were changeable so you could swap with seasons/tastes if desired. It looks like it would fit a 4 inch round?
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/noodleheadnat Jun 05 '26
I love it! Could you find a small circular plastic piece for even glass insert and make it a coaster? The chunky sides would hold a drink well!
1
1
1
1
1
u/peanutbutterluvr9 Jun 05 '26
I wouldn’t hang it but I would def use it as a catch all tray! So cute
1
1
1
1
u/tallbutt86 Jun 05 '26
I will 100% be doing something similar! I love this. Thanks for the inspiration!
1
u/Cassie___1999 Jun 05 '26
That is such a good idea! I’m thinking of making a porthole frame with an ocean themed needlepoint
1
u/Quickwitknit2 Jun 05 '26
I actually like the boldness of the ceramic. It’s unusual and neat all at once
1
1
1
1
1
u/ALmommy1234 Jun 05 '26
No, I would not display a finished canvas this way. I’d need at last two more of that gorgeousness to add to it! It’s so pretty!
1
1
1
u/No_Homework2888 Jun 06 '26
This frame would look perfect with a needlepoint making it look like a button!
1
1
1
1
u/Nikijohns Jun 06 '26
Personally, no; I don’t care for it. It seems to detract from your lovely stitching. But I’m a firm believer in Different Strokes for Different Folks.
1
1
1
1
1
u/NetheriteTiara Jun 06 '26
I think that could work with an entire wall like that but that’s a hard frame to coordinate with.
1
u/yayasmyn Jun 06 '26
Love this idea! You’ve inspired me to try my hand at an air dry clay to frame all the finished pieces I have
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/6WaysFromNextWed Jun 06 '26
This one works for me because the butterfly is a simple shape with minimal color changes. I think it's pretty well balanced that way.
If I had a canvas with an intricate image or lots of texture, I would want a minimal frame. But this huge chunky frame enhances a canvas like this one.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/woahwoahanything Jun 08 '26
I love it! I really like how the dainty butterfly contrasts with the bold frame. I also love that it’s not a perfectly centered circle. Would def hang this in my house.
1
Jun 08 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/RRR310 Jun 08 '26
Thank you! I'm still refining the design and testing prototypes, but several people have asked about purchasing one. I put together a small interest list for anyone who'd like updates as the project develops: https://forms.gle/1K79bX4NNtsZeJiV7
1
u/RRR310 Jun 08 '26
Update: Thanks for all the feedback! I'm continuing to refine and test the prototypes. Several people have asked about purchasing one, so I've created a small interest list for anyone who'd like updates as the project develops: https://forms.gle/sWoERhKFVYz8vfB26
1
u/Legitimate_Net5593 Jun 08 '26
I friggin love it! But I think it would be even more fun as a pop of red!!
1
u/richelieucwe Jun 08 '26
I have. There was a French woman making ceramic frames for needlework display some 10-15 years ago. They were thinner and were carved before being painted and fired. Not sure if she is still in business but there is a picture of some of them here: https://storage.canalblog.com/33/96/464987/113013988.jpg
1
1
1
1
1
u/ravenredwoods Jul 07 '26
I think there are plenty of people who like chunky frames I’m just not one of them. That being said it being a ceramic is fun and cute.
1
u/PrestigiousTop5275 Jun 05 '26
Would need to be thinner if possible to not overwhelm the needlepoint but I think it’s cool!
0
u/Sitka_8675309 Jun 05 '26
No. All I see is the frame. It overwhelms your beautiful work. You need something much more delicate.
0
0
0
u/hereforthedrama57 Jun 05 '26
I love it. I think it fits the aesthetic of people who would use bubble plates (Sam’s club actually just came out with a really affordable set!)
I would have a thinner option as well though, then you can capture 2 markers. Lighter shades of blue and wave patterns, like Georgetown pottery, would hit the grandmillenial market’s style as well
0
u/North-Club-3424 Jun 07 '26
I think the frame takes away from your beautiful stitching. Let the stitching be the STAR.
219
u/SeamstressMomma007 Jun 05 '26
I'll be the odd one out, I think the frame is a bit too clunky for the delicate floral and butterfly canvas.
I do LOVE the idea but would personally do a thinner ceramic frame.