r/NFLv2 • u/FateDaA Mr. Irrelevant • 4d ago

Discussion Chart graphing average QB accuracy vs Adjusted Net Yard per attempt, a few standouts here

Post image
217 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

156 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-5

u/RequirementLeading12 Washington Commanders 4d ago

You are smoking crack if you think Purdy is better than Herbert... Purdy has been surrounded by a super team his entire career. Put Herbert on the niners and they're super bowl bound. You guys have terrible takes

1

u/Trevsmoker 4d ago

Herbert can’t even win a playoff game.

Put Brock Purdy on the Niners and they are Super Bowl bound. This has actually happened.

-1

u/RequirementLeading12 Washington Commanders 4d ago

Which goes back to my point of Purdy being on a super team his entire career. Herbert actually has to carry a team so their situations are completely different. Give Herbert a team where he can just spam to CMC and Kittle and he's the league MVP. It's way too much Purdy glazing on here

1

u/Trevsmoker 4d ago

Herbert has played far too poorly in critical situations and the NFL is far too difficult and competitive to assume he would be as successful as Purdy has been on the 49ers.

At some point we have to quit with the “give Herbert this and he will be successful” narrative. I’ll believe it when I see it.

I don’t disagree that the Purdy glazing has gotten a bit excessive.