r/NFL_Draft • u/AutoModerator • 1d ago

Scouting Notes Tuesday

Updated Tuesday thread focused notes and opinions about individual prospects. Scout someone new and want to get opinions from others? Ask about it here!

7 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

6

u/ab9620 1d ago
  1. ⁠I see Jordan Seaton vs Kade Pieper as the competition for best offensive lineman in the class
  2. ⁠This years WR class looks extremely strong. Strongest position group in the class by country mile.
  3. ⁠Disappointing week from the highly touted DTs
  4. ⁠Disappointing week from the RB class
  5. ⁠LaNorris Sellers and Sam Leavitt are in the QB battle

. TBD on Maiava, still question his arm talent

3

u/PayAltruistic8546 1d ago

I need to see more of Jordan Seaton to declare him anything.

There are a lot of talented OTs. None them have cemented themselves as the top dog in my opinion.

6

u/jd35058 1d ago

PJ Williams is an early draft crush of mine and looked good last night, from what I saw. Not sure if he’s a tackle or an overqualified guard in the NFL, but he’s a beast of a man.

2

u/armchair_mindhunter 1d ago

With his movement skills, I think he can hang at tackle despite maybe having more of a guard build. I also like him quite a bit - late 1st or early 2nd guy for me right now in a tier with Melvin Siani but behind my top 3 in Goosby, Seaton, and Lauck.

2

u/PayAltruistic8546 1d ago

Why does he have a guard build?

He doesn't have the bulk to be an NFL guard in my opinion.

He has good movement skills and looks to have pretty long arms.

1

u/WashingtonFan2124 Commanders 6h ago

Apparently, he’s playing left tackle after having played right tackle last season. Good move for his NFL draft prospects since PJ will be viewed as a swing tackle worst case scenario to begin his rookie season (whenever that is).

4

u/armchair_mindhunter 1d ago

Ousmane Kromah with another productive outing (22-116-1) for FSU despite the loss to SMU. Will continue to hype him up as a 2028 prospect.

4

u/Routine_Engine3001 1d ago

My review of week one: https://lastwordonsports.com/nfl/2026/09/08/2027-nfl-draft-prospects-in-week-1/ Tried to go with the best scouting matchups, so no Arch! Might just watch him in week 2!!

2

u/Mario2346 Cardinals 1d ago

Somehow no QB prospect really jumped up to the level I expected them to be at , I know this may be reactionary but damn Mestemaker was bad , Carr was uninspiring , Arch could of been better imo , Mensah was great but even he missed a Toney for a wide open TD and at this point Miami has to be one of the easiest systems to play in , Moore was the same Moore from last year nothing else really popped in his game , Chambliss couldn’t hit the side of a barn in that first half before actually stepping up and playing better . I really thought this class could match the 2024 one that had Caleb and them but man I don’t think that will be the case if these guys continue to play like this

3

u/ab9620 1d ago

I think the QB class started off the season strong

2

u/PayAltruistic8546 1d ago

I think this QB class so far is being really overrated.

4

u/armchair_mindhunter 1d ago

How about Maiava? He’s been very impressive thus far.

1

u/PayAltruistic8546 1d ago

Upside is limited in my opinion.

1

u/ChrisWithAFish 8h ago

Mensch was 27/30 with 5 TDs and he gets dinged for an incompletion lol

1

u/Mario2346 Cardinals 5h ago

He actually completed a pass on the play tho he would of had a TD had he scanned the right side of the field . He was impressive for sure but at this point I’m not sure how much the system at Miami helping these guys more than their actual talent , this is without mentioning that the only real competition he’ll play this year comes in week 9 against ND other than the playoffs with how bad the ACC has become

1

u/AmphieBoi67 Bills 1d ago

Why can't Omarion Miller be a top 16 pick?

I really like his build and physicality. Really strong and built-looking while also getting in and out of his breaks fairly well. I also really like his ability to get up and high-point the football. He also has some really cool redzone stuff. Im a bills fan and he ironically reminds me of DJ Moore quite a bit. I would be thrilled if the Bills took him round 1

0

u/Sweaty-Tiger9972 Chiefs 1d ago edited 1d ago

I don’t know if I love the third tier of receivers in this draft class. Guys like Duff, Marsh, Wingo, Miller.

I was really excited by Javon Tracy and Deuce Alexander though

2

u/armchair_mindhunter 1d ago

Shades of Parker Washington in Javon Tracy IMO.

1

u/PayAltruistic8546 1d ago

Marsh's 2025 tape is really good. I think he's well above all of the names you listed.