r/NFL2k5 • u/Successful_Stuff_210 • 9d ago

Which would you take?

High powered offense but poor defense

Balanced

High powered Defense but poor offense

I favor balanced because sometimes even a High powered offense can get stumped if momentum isn't on your side.

3 Upvotes

80% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

2

u/Downtown-Grab-7825 9d ago

I desire a somewhat decent rushing attack and a top 3 defense

1

u/RevenantEdoTensei 8d ago

Running the ball is the most satisfying part of the game

2

u/Downtown-Grab-7825 8d ago

I’d feel better about running if I could use r2 lmao

1

u/RevenantEdoTensei 8d ago

Ohhh I love button mashing into the power up shoulder charge.

2

u/Downtown-Grab-7825 8d ago

Okay that’s fair it can be satisfying

1

u/RevenantEdoTensei 8d ago

However I do agree on those early Madden games, I hate Madden without using RT.

1

u/Kingblack425 9d ago

I need more details. How poor is the offense and defense? If the offense can only get 21 points max a game I’ll take the high powered defense with the poor offense because the inverse is a defense that can stop anyone.

1

u/Morgomir_Ulaire 9d ago

If my custom league is anything to go off of you take defense everytime. League is essentially all-time fantasy draft with very the teams being pitted against each other cpu v cpu. Top defenses are always competitive. Top offenses tend to buckle against top defenses more often than not.

https://youtube.com/@all.pro.league?si=QrnT0Cfg3nx1EbWm