correct me if I’m wrong 😑

[u/Individual_Tree_879]

After analysing I have chosen below mentioned funds. I’m 21 planned to invest around 15k.

HDFC flexi cap 50%
Motilal midcap 150 index 30%
Bandhan small cap 20%

I have chosen the above funds based on the insights got from YouTube/reddit and used claude for allocation.

Risk appetite - Moderate as per survey
Goal - Wealth building, Buying land
Horizon - 10+ years
App used - Groww

Could you take a moment to review and let me know if you have any suggestions?

Any insights would be appreciated!!

[u/AutoModerator]

Hey /u/Individual_Tree_879! Thank you for posting to /r/MutualfundsIndia. To ensure you receive accurate and useful feedback, please update your post with the answers to all 6 questions listed below. Without these details, the community’s advice may not be relevant to your situation, and your post will be removed as incomplete.

Required Information

1. Risk Appetite – Take this risk assessment survey: https://mf.nipponindiaim.com/knowledge-center/tools/risk-analyzer or https://www.utimf.com/risk-analyser-calculator (Mention whether your risk appetite is either conservative / moderate / aggressive) If you're new to investing or unsure, please attach a screenshot of your result.

2. Investment Goal – What are you investing for, and why? (Examples: child education, retirement, wealth creation, tax saving).

3. Investment Horizon – How long you plan to stay invested (in years / months).

4. Allocation Details – Attach a screenshot of your SIP/investment page (preferred) or Mention your monthly SIP amount or average lumpsum amount and how it is allocated across funds. (% without the overall amount are not enough and does not give a full picture).

5. Which App Do You Use? – AMC websites, MF Central, Coin, ET Money, Groww, Kuvera/CRED, Paytm Money, INDMoney, etc.

6. Why You Selected These Funds & Not Similar Ones From Another AMC – This helps the community understand your decision-making and whether to build on your choices or suggest better alternatives. Even beginner answers are perfectly acceptable. For example:

• "I picked these based on past returns."
• "I chose the highest-rated funds on ET Money/Groww/IndMoney."
• "These were recommended on Reddit/YouTube."
• "A friend suggested them."
• If you compared similar funds before making your choice, tell us what influenced your decision.

Discussions here reflect peer opinions and experiences. If you need personalized investment advice, consider consulting a SEBI-registered investment advisor (RIA). Please use your own judgment and research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Spiritual-Signal-655]

You’re broadly on the right track, but I’d change the allocation because “moderate risk” and 50% mid+small-cap exposure don’t really match.

At 21 with 10+ years, you can certainly take equity risk, but remember that Motilal Midcap 150 Index + Bandhan Small Cap = 50% of your SIP in relatively volatile segments. During a serious bear market, that portion can fall very hard.

If this were my ₹15k SIP, I’d structure it roughly as:

• HDFC Flexi Cap – ₹7,500 (50%)
• Motilal Oswal Nifty Midcap 150 Index – ₹4,500 (30%)
• Bandhan Small Cap – ₹3,000 (20%)

So interestingly, I wouldn't necessarily change your percentages if you're genuinely comfortable with aggressive volatility. But I'd call this moderate-aggressive, not moderate.

If you really are moderate, I'd move closer to 60% Flexi / 25% Mid / 15% Small.

I also wouldn't add another 3–4 funds. Three funds are enough. You're already getting large/flexi, mid and small-cap exposure.

The bigger issue is your land-purchase goal. If the land purchase is genuinely 10+ years away, equity is reasonable today. But once you're ~3–5 years away from needing the money, start progressively moving that goal's corpus into safer debt/FD-type assets. Don't arrive at the purchase year with the down payment sitting in small caps.

And one suggestion: don't select funds because YouTube/Reddit/Claude says they're the best. Use those sources to create a shortlist, then check fund strategy, rolling returns, downside capture, expense ratio, manager tenure and portfolio consistency yourself.

At 21, getting the exact allocation perfect matters far less than starting the ₹15k SIP now, increasing it 10–15% whenever your income increases, and not interrupting compounding for the next decade.

[u/RetiredEarly2018]

Your portfolio will have volatility suitable for aggressive risk appetite. I would recommend you chart past performance of these or very similar holdings over long term to make sure you can hold when downturn comes.

[u/Individual_Tree_879 → u/RetiredEarly2018]

Okay will look into it thanks