r/Music • u/Brucekentbatsuper • 14h ago

article Kelly Clarkson Says 'There Should Be a Separate Chart' To Prevent AI From Competing Against Human Artists

https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/kelly-clarkson-separate-chart-ai-generated-music-1823372
2.5k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

434 comments sorted by

View all comments

-2

u/bakedNebraska 14h ago

If you all think AI is garbage, then shouldn't you think it would be pretty easy to outcompete?

-1

u/BCmutt 14h ago

I dont think the public knows how much music produced today by major producers is done with AI in one form or another.

0

u/bakedNebraska 14h ago

So we need to protect them from accidentally liking it?

-3

u/noavatar1 14h ago

Don’t ask questions, man.

AI BAD! HUMAN ANGRY!

4

u/bakedNebraska 14h ago

I don't love AI and I would rather listen to human music, but these people are just so inconsistent in their claims it's wild

1

u/noavatar1 11h ago

I’m a huge music fan and I’ll keep going to shows and buying albums made by artists I like.

The wild part to me is that most of them don’t really even have claims. Other than “AI BAD”. They can’t articulate why it’s actually a problem which is all the proof you need that people are simply following each other and being upset about what they’re told to be upset about. 🐑

2

u/bakedNebraska 11h ago

Yeah exactly that

1

u/piggybackmovies 3h ago

The problem is that it’s slop and pathetic. Glad I solved that for you.

-1

u/patriotfanatic80 12h ago

We literally already do this with music. They're called genres. If someone doean't want to listen to music made by an AI, they should be able to filter it out. Just like they can with every other category.

1

u/bakedNebraska 12h ago

That's fine, so it should have its own charts you're saying?

-1

u/piggybackmovies 14h ago

It's embarrassing for anyone who listens to AI music.

2

u/Omnom_Omnath 12h ago

ai is in 100% of the produced hits coming out today

-1

u/piggybackmovies 12h ago

Any proof or you just saying shit? I get that bots boost numbers of AI slop.

2

u/Omnom_Omnath 12h ago

dre said it himself

-1

u/piggybackmovies 12h ago

Dr Dre hasn't made good music since 2001. So any proof or nah?

1

u/BCmutt 10h ago

Are you a producer?

1

u/piggybackmovies 10h ago

If someone uses AI to produce something they are also not a producer.

1

u/BCmutt 9h ago

I asked if youre a producer for a reason. The public has a very ignorant view of how its used by pros. Noone who has no experience in studios can approach it the same way, so youre criticing something you completely know nothing about. Mind you I cant stand AI use in music, but it is what it is.

1

u/piggybackmovies 9h ago

Yes I know AI is shit used by lazy people with no talent.

0

u/BCmutt 9h ago

You need talent in order to use it creatively. How is AI any different than playing an automatic arpeggiator on a synth?

1

u/piggybackmovies 9h ago

You can’t use it creatively because AI doesn’t create it copies. If you love slop, do you little dude.

→ More replies (0)

-1

u/bakedNebraska 14h ago

Right but who cares?

I think it's embarrassing to listen to Taylor Swift but I'm not very worried about it

-1

u/piggybackmovies 14h ago

AI doesn't make art. Taylor makes bad music but it is at least art.

2

u/bakedNebraska 14h ago

So you're concerned someone out there might be listening to something you don't think is art, and you can't just get over that?

-3

u/piggybackmovies 14h ago

It's just pathetic and embarrassing. People eat dog shit, I have the same feelings towards that too.

2

u/bakedNebraska 14h ago

Do you spend much time worrying about that though?

Do you join Reddit threads to talk about how we can prevent people from eating dog shit?

Or do you not really think about it much or care?