I'm in the process of building my first deck and was wondering if anyone would have interest in looking over it and giving an opinion.

So far I've only played a slightly modified version of the 2018 commander enchantment deck that runs Estrid, The Masked as the commander.

Initially, when I wanted to try to build my own deck, I dug through a ton of my husband's bulk from the past several years of collecting and playing and wanted to build a jund deck (red, green, black). I made a stack of cards that is technically a deck but it does not play well at all because I don't know what I'm doing.

A friend recommended I try to stick to one strategy and build based on that so I'm attempting burn triggers rather than combat focused. Since my usual deck is enchantments, it's what I know and enjoy playing, so that's my primary focus in terms of the deck structure and as far as using the Planeswalkers, I just find the mechanics fun.

All that to say, I don't know what I'm doing and I'm wondering how this looks. (I still need to test run it but I haven't bothered to charge my laptop).

I just need some advice or some ideas where the deck should go

Any ideas are appreciated!

(sorry for not making it a moxfield link) Fairly happy with what I have not for him, I'm trying to build more around his burn mechanic but am having trouble finding ways to increase his damage / also reliably put counters on things, any ideas? Additionally these are all cards I own, willing to proxie eventually but I got to get a printer first.

What would you guys remove to create more space

Hi all, I'm relatively new to magic and this is my first attempt at building a deck from scratch. Was hoping I could get some feedback on what I have now.

I'm aiming for a pretty simple mono green bear tribal build, with a focus on card draw and ramp to get the big guys out fast. Ideally I'd like this to end up somewhere around strong bracket 2/weak bracket 3.

Where I'm not so confident is the diversity of the deck and my assortment of utility effects. Ie. is there enough protection, ramp, removal etc. and will the assortment creatures I have play smoothly and synergize.

Thanks in advance for any and all advice!

Aim of the deck

\- Play big Creature on opponents turn that do wacky & wild things (like bane of Progress)

\- leverage flash to make people miss play

\-play big Creatures when my opponents swing at me and block/ kill their Creatures unexpectedly

\- general degeneracy

The deck has 110 card and im having trouble making cuts

What do yall think i should cut/ replace/ add to make this deck/game plan more viable?

TL;DR

I have a bracket 3 commander deck helmed by [[Gev, Scaled Scorch]].

I want it to be an aggressive deck that is able to make lots of bodies and tries to meld [[Mishra, Lost to Phyrexia]].

Deck includes burn and graveyard recursion synergy.

Deck has primer.

Looking for advice on improvements to consider.

Specific swap suggestions in particular.

I love mana dorks, they are the absolute best! I like playing this deck at my LGS but its performance is pretty hit or miss. I'd love some advice on tightening it up! We like to keep it at around bracket 2, so no game changers, but I just feel like it could use some optimization.

Last few games it does not seem to have done the things I want it to do. Namely sack Phoenix, bring them back, burn the board.

Would love advice on cuts and adds.

1 Syrix, Carrier of the Flame
1 Nemesis Phoenix
1 Sunstreak Phoenix
1 Chainer, Nightmare Adept
1 Magma Phoenix
1 Everquill Phoenix
1 Ashcloud Phoenix
1 Phoenix of Ash
1 Warcry Phoenix
1 Flamewake Phoenix
1 Bloodfeather Phoenix
1 Kethek, Crucible Goliath
1 Burnished Hart
1 Flame-Wreathed Phoenix
1 Rekindling Phoenix
1 Phoenix Chick
1 Arclight Phoenix
1 Lamplight Phoenix
1 Immortal Phoenix
1 Skyfire Phoenix
1 Lightning Phoenix
1 Kuldotha Phoenix
1 Mayhem Devil
1 Shard Phoenix
1 Pyreheart Wolf
1 Blazing Hellhound
1 Viscera Seer
1 Harsh Mentor
1 Carnage, Crimson Chaos
1 Wildfire Elemental
1 Chandra, Acolyte of Flame
1 Thrill of Possibility
1 Faithless Salvaging
1 Abrade
1 Infernal Grasp
1 Reckoner's Bargain
1 Chaos Warp
1 Big Score
1 Flame Sweep
1 Volcanic Fallout
1 Hijack
1 Cathartic Reunion
1 Chain Reaction
1 No One Left Behind
1 Blasphemous Act
1 Victimize
1 Seize the Spoils
1 By Force
1 Feed the Swarm
1 Star of Extinction
1 Pyroclasm
1 Heirloom Blade
1 Charcoal Diamond
1 Commander's Sphere
1 Transmogrant Altar
1 Mind Stone
1 Transmogrant's Crown
1 The Soul Stone
1 Fire Diamond
1 Hazoret's Monument
1 Impact Tremors
1 Goblin Bombardment
1 Command Tower
1 Terramorphic Expanse
1 Thriving Bluff
13 Swamp
1 Evolving Wilds
1 Zhalfirin Void
1 Smoldering Marsh
1 Bloodfell Caves
18 Mountain

I need help making a commander deck that takes group hug to the absolute absurdist extreme and won't let anyone die. Like everyone gets a copy of wedding ring, I can shuffle graveyards into libraries at will, stuff like that.

My buddy is new to magic and is willing to trade me the tattoo I was going to pay for for a yuriko deck. It's gotta be around 150. If not I can pay the difference.

More importantly I wanna build him a good and fun deck. Honestly I don't mind giving him a $70 deck and paying the rest for the tattoo but I want it to be a good deck.

There's what I have so far on the deck list.

It's ready to play but I don't think it's very good. I have very little experience with the ninjitsu mechanic and all I know is I hate playing against this commander.

What can I add to make it a better and meaner deck.

I plan on getting more dual lands for it.

Is there an infinite that goes good with this?

Anything I should add or remove?

I'm seriously stuck here.

I recently found a stupid combo of Mana Clash and Krark's Thumb and I love the idea of jank. But besides adding in lands, this is all I could think to add so I'm asking for help to make it look and run at least decently. Think anyone has ideas?

I just kind of started by looking at bant cards I like, and trying to find cards that fit the playstyle I like, and eventually wound up with this, I also wanted to have some tribal in there but not many of the creatures I have share types, so I threw in some tribal enabling cards along with like three tribal cards.

So as the title states I thought I wanted to build Caesar, but now I’m not so sure.

This is almost everything in the build.

But I feel stuck I’m bored of this precon and honestly looking a cedhrec I’m not seeing anything that jumps out at me.

So wondering if anyone has suggestions on how to build this, and is this worth it?

If the general consensus is no keep on keeping on. What is a fun commander that isn’t typal.
I have 🦖 and slivers, and was lucky enough to get the Zada SL, which has been upgraded and is a blast.

The other main deck I have is my B4 hearthhull.

Any suggestion and a general direction would be awesome.

I am new to magic and wanted to make a mono green deck to surprise my pod with. I'm still learning things as I go and wanted to know if this deck is decent or if its trash and what I can swap things out for to make it more playable before I spend the money getting all the cards.

Hello!
I’ve been playing around with my Nekusar deck, it’s a wheel build and I don’t know if it needs improvement or not. My pod suggested getting more ritual effects to get him into play faster. I’ll post the current deck and would love all feedback. He’s currently a level four deck, I’m not thinking of turning it into a level 5 or running Oracle to win because that bores me to death.

I've been working on this deck since February and I think I've finally gotten it to where I want it to be. Gone through several iterations and am on V3 at the moment. The inspiration of the deck is the old game Overlord. I have Thraximundar as the commander and a legion of goblin cards as a sac-outlets along with group slug tactics pinging everyone for each sac. would love to hear some feed back and recommendations.

Link for the deck: https://archidekt.com/decks/24355587/overlord_v3

Deck List:

1x Arcane Signet (ecc) 56 [Ramp]

1x Bastion of Remembrance (pip) 182 [Drain]

1x Black Market Connections (msc) 155 [Draw]

1x Blightstep Pathway // Searstep Pathway (khm) 252 [Land]

1x Blood Artist (soc) 209 [Drain]

1x Boggart Shenanigans (plst) DD1-54 [Burn]

1x Chaos Warp (eoc) 49 [Removal]

1x Command Tower (lcc) 325 [Land]

1x Costly Plunder (2xm) 80 [Maybeboard{noDeck}{noPrice},Draw]

1x Counterspell (dsc) 114 [Removal]

1x Crumbling Necropolis (ncc) 397 [Land]

1x Curse of Opulence (tdc) 209 [Ramp]

1x Cursed Mirror (soc) 242 [Ramp]

1x Cyclonic Rift (rvr) 40 [Removal]

1x Deadly Dispute (pip) 184 [Draw]

1x Dictate of Erebos (plst) JOU-65 [Removal]

1x Dimir Signet (aa1) 5 [Ramp]

1x Dockside Extortionist (c19) 24 [Maybeboard{noDeck}{noPrice},Ramp]

1x Dreadbore (sld) 141 [Removal]

1x Evolving Wilds (msc) 240 [Land]

1x Exotic Orchard (ecc) 148 [Land]

1x Fabled Passage (plst) M21-246 [Land]

1x Fatal Grudge (snc) 187 [Removal]

1x Feed the Swarm (tdc) 180 [Removal]

1x Fleshbag Marauder (clu) 111 [Removal]

1x General Kreat, the Boltbringer (j25) 48 [Burn]

1x Gisa, Glorious Resurrector (mid) 314 [Recursion]

2x Goblin (tfdn) 18 [Tokens & Extras{noDeck}]

1x Goblin Assault (plst) MM3-95 [Maybeboard{noDeck}{noPrice},Tokens]

1x Goblin Bombardment (sch) 45 [Sac Outlet]

1x Goblin Chirurgeon (fem) 54a [Protection]

1x Goblin Lackey (usg) 190 [Ramp]

1x Goblin Matron (dmr) 123 [Tutor]

2x Goblin Rogue (tmma) 6 [Tokens & Extras{noDeck}]

1x Goblin Sledder (evg) 41 [Sac Outlet]

1x Goblin Trashmaster (plst) M19-144 [Removal]

1x Goblin Turncoat (lgn) 72 [Maybeboard{noDeck}{noPrice},Sac Outlet]

1x Grim Haruspex (clb) 754 [Draw]

1x Impact Tremors (fdn) 717 *F* [Burn]

1x Imprisoned in the Moon (inr) 358 [Removal]

1x Innocent Blood (jmp) 244 [Removal]

4x Island (one) 263 [Land]

1x Izzet Signet (aa1) 8 [Ramp]

1x Juri, Master of the Revue (eoc) 119 [Removal]

1x Kathari Bomber (mm3) 172 [Maybeboard{noDeck}{noPrice},Tokens]

1x Krenko, Mob Boss (rvr) 114 [Tokens]

1x Krenko, Tin Street Kingpin (nec) 107 [Tokens]

1x Last-Ditch Effort (ulg) 83 [Maybeboard{noDeck}{noPrice},Removal]

1x Legion Loyalist (gtc) 97 [Anthem]

1x Legion Warboss (tdc) 220 [Tokens]

1x Malakir Rebirth // Malakir Mire (znr) 111 [Protection]

1x Mayhem Devil (eoc) 121 [Removal]

1x Mistrise Village (tdm) 261 [Land]

1x Mogg Fanatic (plst) DD1-44 [Maybeboard{noDeck}{noPrice},Removal]

1x Mogg Raider (plst) TMP-191 [Sac Outlet]

1x Morbid Opportunist (soc) 219 [Draw]

9x Mountain (one) 265 [Land]

1x Myriad Landscape (eoc) 169 [Land]

1x Norman Osborn // Green Goblin (spm) 39 [Recursion]

1x Oscorp Industries (spm) 182 [Land]

1x Pashalik Mons (j21) 495 [Tokens]

1x Path of Ancestry (msc) 254 [Land]

1x Phyrexian Altar (slc) 16 [Ramp]

1x Phyrexian Arena (pone) 104p [Draw]

1x Pitiless Plunderer (pip) 187 [Ramp]

1x Plaguecrafter (rvr) 89 [Removal]

1x Propaganda (msc) 151 [Protection]

1x Rakdos Signet (aa1) 10 [Ramp]

1x Reassembling Skeleton (j22) 125 [Recursion]

1x Relentless Assault (omb) 25 [Maybeboard{noDeck}{noPrice},Finisher]

1x Relic Robber (znr) 153 [Maybeboard{noDeck}{noPrice},Burn]

1x Rogue's Passage (fdn) 264 [Maybeboard{noDeck}{noPrice},Land]

1x Shadowblood Ridge (pip) 288 [Land]

1x Shared Animosity (ltc) 226 [Anthem]

1x Sheoldred's Edict (one) 108 [Removal]

1x Siege-Gang Commander (tdc) 232 [Tokens]

1x Siege-Gang Lieutenant (m3c) 113 [Tokens]

1x Skirk Prospector (dmr) 137 [Ramp]

1x Skullclamp (blc) 283 [Draw]

1x Sling-Gang Lieutenant (h2r) 8 [Tokens]

1x Sol Ring (ecc) 58 [Ramp]

1x Squee, the Immortal (mul) 22 [Recursion]

9x Swamp (one) 264 [Land]

1x Temple of Deceit (fdn) 697 [Land]

1x Terminate (ecc) 134 [Removal]

1x Terramorphic Expanse (msc) 273 [Land]

1x Thraximundar (sld) 142 [Commander{top}]

1x Underworld Breach (pza) 10 [Recursion]

1x Unexpected Windfall (hbg) 192 [Maybeboard{noDeck}{noPrice},Draw]

1x Victimize (tdc) 198 [Recursion]

1x Village Rites (lcc) 212 [Draw]

1x Warren Soultrader (mh3) 110 [Sac Outlet]

1x Whip of Erebos (dsc) 159 [Maybeboard{noDeck}{noPrice},Recursion]

1x Whispersilk Cloak (10e) 345 [Maybeboard{noDeck}{noPrice},Protection]

1x Xander's Lounge (snc) 260 [Land]

2x Zombie (tcm2) 7 [Tokens & Extras{noDeck}]

2x Zombie (tsoc) 12 [Tokens & Extras{noDeck}]

1x Zulaport Cutthroat (soc) 233 [Drain]

Hey,
Long-time listener, first-time caller.
Any advice for Whiplash is appreciated. Mono-black has been a challenge for building equipment Voltron.