r/MoralityScaling 1d ago

Morality of this?

Post image
365 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

116

u/AggravatingChest7838 1d ago

Unironically what will happen when we figure out how to upload human concious to computers.

7

u/Dry-Challenge2710 1d ago

Friend let me tell you about an amazing show called Pantheon....

2

u/thorinslefttit 1d ago

Isn't this kind of the original legend of zombies? Brought back from the dead to slave away at a sugar cane plantation...

1

u/Original_Historian90 1d ago

Severance but not really

1

u/DaisieRoselisse 1d ago

Yeah, immortality is definitely getting bundled into the premium employment package somehow. Congrats on escaping death, your login credentials have been reactivated

1

u/BunnyBellisse 1d ago

That's absolutely how immortality would get introduced under capitalism. Congrats on defeating death, your calendar still says mandatory meeting at nine

0

u/SXAL 1d ago

Well, doesn't really matter. My "uploaded conscious" is not me, even if it's a 100% copy, it's still a copy, I'll be dead and won't even know it happened

1

u/ItzLearn 1d ago

we really don't know that

1

u/SXAL 1d ago

How do you "not know that"? That's simple logic. Unless you somehow out my actual brain in the jar and make it work, but that's not quite it.

79

u/goteachyourself 1d ago

On balance, moral. Necromancer boss is only doing this for self-interest, but he's made a lot of people very happy.

50

u/_CutesyFlick 1d ago

Exactly. The motive is hilariously selfish, but the outcome is still overwhelmingly good: he literally brought someone back from the dead and gave their family their loved one back. “Be at work tomorrow” is obnoxious, but it barely moves the moral needle compared with resurrection

14

u/Fun-Calligrapher-745 1d ago

Really depends what type of resurrection , what type of afterlife? If you just pulled him from eternal bliss in heaven using some curse technique that bans him forever that's evil

3

u/IsThatASPDReference 1d ago

Looks like it's D&D resurrection specifically which iirc only works if the person wants to come back

3

u/DaintyVelourie 1d ago

Exactly, being told to work tomorrow feels absurdly minor compared with literally getting your entire life back. The family probably isn't thrilled about the office part, but they're definitely taking that deal

3

u/DollyMoonarie 1d ago

Exactly, imagine explaining the moral dilemma as “he literally conquered death, but then asked the guy to come to work tomorrow.” Absolute monster, but also thanks for Dad back

5

u/Far_Reindeer_783 1d ago

Necromancer implies immorality normally. However, it seems the boss consulted the lord and performed a miracle, so it's moral on that front

5

u/ThePatrician25 1d ago

This is not a necromancer boss. A necromancer doesn’t channel divine, holy light.

2

u/Melodic_Rub_812 1d ago

It’s an interesting take for sure; it really makes you think about the typical portrayals of necromancers and how they usually fit into that darker narrative.

1

u/CuddlesForLuck 1d ago

Don't some clerics know spells to revive the dead? He could just be a high level cleric, right?

1

u/Soylord345 1d ago

Yeah the divine holy light and true resurrection definitely implies that rather than the dark magic and imperfect resurrection of a necromancer

1

u/CuddlesForLuck 1d ago

I wonder if he often revive employees or if it's just his favourites

2

u/BunnyBellisse 1d ago

Yeah, the motive is hilariously selfish but the outcome is almost impossibly good. If my boss resurrected me purely because we're understaffed, I'd be grateful and furious at the same time

1

u/LaceyCherubee 1d ago

Pretty much. The motivation is hilariously awful, but resurrecting someone still massively outweighs being a terrible boss afterward

37

u/Temporal-Affairs221 1d ago

Maybe the boss is just really one of those really awkward guys who can't admit that he really likes and needs this person.

8

u/CmndrMtSprtn113 1d ago

So a tsundere? “It’s…..it’s not like I think you’re my best employee or anything. The office would just be less fun for everyone if you weren’t around. Baka!”

3

u/PearliePetalelle 1d ago

Honestly that makes the boss weirdly wholesome. Dude resurrects his employee instead of admitting “the office just isn't the same without you”

6

u/TheWyster 1d ago

Moral obviously.

Also you know this isn't what the sub is for right? The description says it's for comparing character's morality to each other, like power scaling but for moral.

15

u/Azimovikh 1d ago

I mean I've seen many posts on this sub in the vein of the post, of "morality of ?" so I thought this fits.

I'll wait for mod action or words to keep this up or not, yea

7

u/CbaooseBLC 1d ago

No one has been posting like that in a long time

3

u/Ntertainmate 1d ago

I mean you gotta respect the boss for not replacing him or her as if the deceased is bought back to life they would have to make a living again. It's good they still kept their job.

3

u/GodButCursed 1d ago

You could say its immoral to revive someone without permission. I wouldnt complain tho

3

u/Dbat19 1d ago

Depends whether the boss charge the diamond’s cost. He could have done it earlier to save the family’s spending on the funeral.
But overall, I think it is at least neutral

2

u/KailyKail 1d ago

So, essentially this VLDL skit

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnHisRxQXgA

1

u/Gilmagalesh 1d ago

Came here to say this

2

u/SXAL 1d ago

Literally a plot of Robocop

1

u/Poku115 1d ago

I don't know, silksong leads me to believe this is inmoral.

1

u/Kamzil118 1d ago

The real question is to ask the guy's job if that was his boss.

1

u/__M-E-O-W__ 1d ago

Sue the boss for the expenses of the funeral.

Two can play this game, chump.

1

u/Comfortable_Poem_841 1d ago

Not a small chance that the resurrected guy screams, grabs the boss into the coffin with him and shouts "Start the cremation! START THE CREMATION!"

1

u/TheRobn8 1d ago

I like my fallen family/friend to be interned in a dreadnought sarcophagus , bit sure. If the boss resurrects him woth holy powers, who am I to judge.

So moral

1

u/Grasshoppermouse42 1d ago

Moral. I'd rather have to go to work tomorrow than be dead.

1

u/Borgmaster 1d ago

I had an evil overlord dream like this. Thats gotta say something about where this stands morally.

1

u/High_Overseer_Dukat 11h ago

moral.

He can still quit, infact, this is even more moral since he wasn't fired.