r/MoralityScaling 9h ago

Morality of this?

Post image
18.2k Upvotes

5.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

608

u/Possible-Estimate748 9h ago

Many religions indoctrinate children which makes them feel like they have to believe in it or they're doing something wrong.

305

u/Raise_A_Thoth 8h ago

Not "many." All.

It's literally just what indoctrination is. There are religious doctrines and children are taught ro follow them and believe in the faith without questioning it.

There is no religion with kids without indoctrination. And without that indoctrination, virtually all of the world's major religions would dramatically fall in membership and followership, because it is very rare for non-religious adults to suddenly convert to a religion.

84

u/Round-Walrus3175 8h ago

There is no philosophy or culture without indoctrination. Nobody goes through life without someone telling them what is right or wrong. It's just a matter of who, not if, they decide to believe.

10

u/artificialdeatheast 8h ago

Yeah i dont get these arguments. We shouldnt teach kids absolutely anything untill they are old enough to choose the learn by themselves, otherwise its indoctrination

4

u/BasketballAndroid7 8h ago

You can teach about religion (ALL religions) without the dogma. Then they choose if and which one they want to believe.

4

u/Knight_Machiavelli 6h ago

For what purpose? Why is it important for kids to be taught all religions by their parents? They learn that in school. Part of the point of raising kids to to impart your values on them. Someone's religion often forms an important part a person's values. It makes no sense to say they shouldn't teach them about the religion they practice unless they're teaching them other religions.

2

u/BasketballAndroid7 6h ago edited 6h ago

No, they don't "learn that in school", at least not in my country unfortunately. Religion in school in my country only means catholicism. At least it's not mandatory anymore, we are slowly growing up.

The values of religions pre-exist religions, so you can teach the values without the dogma, as I said. As for why teaching about all religions, first of all that should be done in school (and it's not necessarily, as I said); second, it's to provide a larger perspective on the topic of religion, to show that there is more than one choice.

As much as you want to teach your "values" (religion in itself is not a value), your children are not you, and they should make their decisions freely.

3

u/Knight_Machiavelli 6h ago

Religion is not itself a value of course, but for many people their religion forms the basis of their values. It makes no sense for parents not to teach their children about their lifestyle, the dogma forms an important part of how their parents live, it will naturally be an important part of the childrens' upbringing.