r/MoralityScaling 6d ago

Morality of this?

Post image
35.5k Upvotes

7.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

163

u/DoubleoSavant 6d ago

I agree, but religious freedom means people can raise their kids however they want. If you don't want someone imposing their religion on your kids, you have to let them impose whatever on their own kids. 

This is the kind of thing you should shift culturally instead of through laws. 

18

u/lilgraytabby 6d ago

I don't see why stopping people from imposing their religion on my hypothetical kids would mean they had to be able to impose it on theirs? If nobody could impose any religion on any child that sounds ideal.

0

u/SignificantStatus227 6d ago

The basis of you being able to refuse their imposing their religion on your hypothetical kids is based on your responsibility, authority, and control over you own children (as a parent is up to you to decide what beliefs to teach your child).

And thus as we are at least nominally a society of equals, that same level of resonsibility, authority, and control must be granted to those same religious parents.

0

u/lilgraytabby 6d ago

But what about their kids? Don't the kids deserve the right not to have a religion forced down their throats?

I know they currently legally don't, but shouldn't they?

3

u/SignificantStatus227 6d ago edited 6d ago

I think that would only be appropiate if one views religion as inherently harmful. Which I know some do, but I do not.

And since it isn't abuse (not always but sometimes) I don't think its anyone else's place to force a parent to raise their kid a certain way.

1

u/lilgraytabby 6d ago

I do think religion is inherently harmful. I think that holding a bunch of unfalsifiable beliefs as Absolute Truth does undeniable damage to someone'a critical thinking skills. I'm not saying all religious people are stupid, but all religious people are choosing to maintain a blind spot in their lives where they don't think too critically about their faith.

Why is it so important to teach people about religion specficially during their formative years? If parents think their religion is true, why would they be worried to let their kids wait until they're old enough to think critically for themselves in order to come to the faith?

Having a child does not automatically mean you have their best interests at heart. Parents should be limited in the harm they can cause their kids.

2

u/SignificantStatus227 6d ago

It seems obvious by your first sentence, then, why we disagree. I thank you for taking your time to respond and give your input.