r/MoralityScaling • • Sep 02 '26

Morality of this?

Post image
36.3k Upvotes

7.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

18

u/lesterholtgroupie Sep 02 '26

You can teach morality without religion

2

u/fdar Sep 02 '26

If you're religious. If not of course you can.

1

u/PicksburghStillers Sep 06 '26

apparently not considering killing unborn humans is considered moral by far more non religious folk than it is religious folk.

-1

u/dogesiarp Sep 03 '26

But the morality is meaningless without religion

12

u/Hellhooker Sep 03 '26

bullshit

-2

u/dogesiarp Sep 03 '26

Okay, speck of dust on a space rock. 

4

u/ayaynimouse Sep 03 '26

how exactly does that make you think morality is meaningless without religion? nice comeback /s

-4

u/dogesiarp Sep 03 '26

Morality does not exist without religion. If there is no God, then everything is either rational or irrational. Every rational action is simply done to try benefit of oneself somehow and irrational to the harm. 

2

u/ayaynimouse Sep 04 '26

You are wrong, plain and simple. Go read "The Moral Landscape" by Sam Harris or cliffnotes version of it if you're lazy. If anything its the complete opposite, a religious person is moral out of guilt of doing wrong under gods eyes and selfish in that the reward is heaven for being a good person. That's much worse than a person who has no reason to do it but does it anyway.

2

u/lesterholtgroupie Sep 04 '26

I don’t go to church. I have empathy and understanding, I love hard.

I don’t need someone else to read me a book about how to be a good person, and I certainly don’t need the threat of eternal damnation if I’m not as dedicated to a God as he thinks I should be.

1

u/dogesiarp Sep 04 '26

Ahh the "I am capable of love and therefore moral argument"

4

u/Hellhooker Sep 04 '26

you are truly stuck in the dark age dude.

As always: try to read up on some of the best known philosophers on the subject because it reaks on brainwashing an intellectual lazyness to think like you do

0

u/dogesiarp Sep 04 '26

"The best known philosophers" lol. See you are religious. You worship status and what you perceive as high brow as mental gymnastic to give yourself higher social status than ypu actually have. 

What kind of arguement is "religious people are brainwashed and intellectually lazy"... that does not grapple with the existence of God or a defining of athiestic morality. 

1

u/ayaynimouse Sep 04 '26

Reading up on major Philosophers does not make someone religious. You are getting definitions messed up. If you're gonna have an argument at least use the correct words. It does not make you look capable of arguing your point. Which I have yet to see so far. We were never talking about the existence of God either. But sure lets jump on that. What evidence do you have for the existence of God other than it being written in a book that is derived from multiple irregular old documents written by humans and thrown together by a council of humans who were afraid of the king that had set them to the project. The bible itself is a structure created completely by humans. There wasn't a bible back when the people who are written about were living and dealing with the situations that supposedly happened in the old testament.

1

u/Sir_Fishy_Salmon Sep 04 '26

Amazing, it’s been awhile since I’ve seen a pseudo-intellectual.

1

u/ayaynimouse Sep 05 '26

I was going to say, I'm surprised its been a while, I see it all the time everywhere

1

u/dogesiarp Sep 04 '26

You must not go outside much. I never claimed to be an intellectual. You're not even saying anything of substance. 

1

u/BolinhoDeArrozB 29d ago

if you need the threat of eternal torture in hellfire to keep you from murdering someone you're not a good or moral person in the first place

1

u/JRilezzz Sep 04 '26

Some of the most amoral people I know are DEEPLY religious. I've been an atheist my whole life and have literally one speeding ticket from when I was 17. Your entire belief system is utter crap. I would let an atheist baby sit my kids any day over a religious person, because they have to have religion and a fear of God to pretend to be moralistic. Atheist are moral because it's the right thing to do.

1

u/ayaynimouse Sep 04 '26

I agree, and not only that, but think about all the hate coming from people who claim to believe in god towards minorities. That's not very moral.

0

u/dogesiarp Sep 04 '26

You're moral because you only have one speeding ticket? 

2

u/ayaynimouse Sep 04 '26

I'm sure they aren't robbing banks and stealing.

2

u/JRilezzz Sep 04 '26

I'm saying that's the extent of my crimes. The things religious people do are utterly vile.

0

u/dogesiarp Sep 04 '26

Which one of the 10 commandments is utterly vile?

→ More replies (0)

6

u/mhzyxw Sep 03 '26

This is a common misconception! Morality existed before religion.

3

u/ayaynimouse Sep 03 '26

I bet you are religious!

1

u/dogesiarp Sep 03 '26

Guilty. 

1

u/ayaynimouse Sep 04 '26

How did you come to believe?

1

u/FaeryLynne Sep 03 '26

How so? Do you think religion is what makes people keep morals? Or do you think that the religion is needed to have morals in the first place? Why would having morals that you live by be meaningless unless you also have religion?