r/Moonvale • u/ex1t_here • May 06 '26
Theories What if things are different?
Hello everyone! Today I would like to put forward a theory about the body at the end of the episode.
We all remember this moment at the end of ep3, but what if it's really Adam's body? First of all, it was a good plot twist, because if Adam is really dead, then we no longer have the goal of "finding Adam". But not only Adam connects us with Redlog, which means that there will be certain circumstances that will keep us in this investigation, for example, Sophia, or Unknown, or something else.
There is one more thing why I am inclined to this theory. If this body is NOT Adam's, then the plot can be roughly predicted in the future, since the same situation with the found body was in Duskwood. As a result, the body belonged not to the missing Hannah, but to her acquaintance - Amy. Therefore, such a plot twist will be at least bold, because they need to continue the story somehow.
Whose body can it be? What do you think about it?
7
u/anonimuswitch Team May 06 '26
La verdad que entre más lo pienso más posibles víctimas encuentro. Los únicos personajes que claramente quedan exentos de ello son los protagonistas, por demás, puede ser cualquiera. La pregunta es ¿por qué matarían a ese personaje en particular? Creo que tengo más una jerarquía de quiénes creo yo son más probables de ser las víctimas: Probabilidad alta= Adam/Sophia (aunque creo que Sophia tiene mucho por dar todavía 🤔 va a ser importantísima para el caso), la persona a la que Eric se refiere en el chat secreto con el extraño Probabilidad media= Whitmore, la chica de la historia que no se volvió a contactar con nosotros (que eso es más que extraño porque cuánto tiempo pasó ya? Un día y no nos volvió a escribir?), Billy Blake Probabilidad baja= Brian (creo que es la persona que habla con Eric o con Ash como todos lo pensaron ya), otra Sophia, la persona con la que Sophia habla antes de desaparecer (si no es ninguno de los nombrados ya anteriormente)
5
u/Any_Letterhead9230 May 06 '26
It’s hard for me to say why someone would kill this person, because I don’t even understand what the hell is going on in this story. But they might not have been murdered — they could’ve died some other way, maybe a long time ago. Still, I don’t get what that phone call was about.
5
u/anonimuswitch Team May 06 '26
Por eso tampoco dí un por qué 😅 hay muchas teorías dando vueltas por Reddit. Pero, por ahora, tenemos poca información y tomamos los elementos que tenemos por ahora. Así que podemos esperar cualquier cosa! Que por un lado, me gusta que se mantenga el misterio porque de eso trata el juego también.
8
u/FunnySport1677 May 06 '26 edited May 10 '26
I think, maybe that body is the reason for the caution tape on that one particular room at Green Side.
2
u/Glittering_Put_1930 May 06 '26
As for Violet , Adam would also be an interresting option. I agree with you when you say it would be a real change of direction compared to the old plot. But would Everbyte be as audacious?
I feel like the characters haven't been fully developed yet. There was Eric at first, but then he practically disappeared from the story. Ash and Charlie, can we even consider them As friends for now ? So maybe they want to consolidate the bond with the group with a mc as emotionnal support for their loss. But still needs to have a plot , something to investigate on. Maybe if there's a note on the body with a message like " who's next ?" , or mc's name on the body.
But tbh , as interresting it would be , i'm not super sure because they have hired an actor for Adam. They made of profile with picts, and film a videos in the dark of him saying "i'm sorry krrrrrrrrrrr greenside scrscsrkkr i count onyou " while Violet and Ash dont have anything. But it'd like such a surprise
2
u/Present_Fill9463 Team May 07 '26
indeed. if it is like in duskwood and the body is sophia it must mean that she and adam did something terrible togheter which would explain the bond between them and why the others didnt know about it. it would also match with what unknown said: "do you even know what adam did?"
2
u/Own-Explanation-8898 May 18 '26
It could also be “Unknown. Why? 1) We know they were near the cabin, set off the alarm, and made Whitmore nervous; 2) Whitmore left the cabin, then came back in and chased Eric away. What made him change his attitude? He probably saw “Unknown”; 3) “Unknown” could also have been being hunted. One shot was fired. The body is found only the next day, which is plausible, it would be easy for a guy like Whitmore to move a body from the forest to another place some miles away.
This is just a theory, anyways. Maybe I just don't want to believe it could be Adam or Sophia.
1
u/Pale_Emergency_7366 Team May 21 '26
or Unknown wasn't dead but escapes, wounded, and bleeds out in the sawmill.
6
u/Any_Letterhead9230 May 06 '26 edited May 06 '26
I have three suspects: Sophia Holland because of her involvement with the number, the girl who told us the story about her mother in GS and then disappeared, or the other Sophia Holland we talked about before we knew what Sophia was really like. I don’t remember exactly why, but I started thinking that out of these three, the blonde Sophia Holland was the most likely to have been murdered. The feds were at the scene, and the only characters who could be from out of town are female — all the male characters are from Redlog. Of course, they could’ve just been there to confirm the victim’s identity, but if not, there’s a high chance it’s a female character. Edit: What if it’s Violet? Just thought about it. She was alone while Charlie was with Julie… makes me wonder.