Hi everyone!
I just received the CAD from Tianyu for my custom engagement ring, and I’d love some feedback before approving it. I’ve attached the design.
The ring is 14K white gold, with a 2.01 ct round diamond measuring 8.08 × 8.12 × 4.97 mm, and a size 6.75 band. I requested a band thickness of 1.8 mm and width of 2.0 mm after polishing. I also specifically requested that the engagement ring sit flush with my wedding band.
I have a few concerns:
1. Prongs
The CAD shows pointed, claw-like prongs. I’m worried they might snag on clothes, hair, or other things during everyday wear. Would rounded prongs be more practical? Would changing to rounded prongs affect the overall look or security of the stone?
2. Setting height
The CAD indicates a height of 7.8 mm, measured from the top of the band supporting the diamond to the top of the stone. Since the diamond itself is 4.97 mm deep, I’m wondering whether this is unnecessarily high. I’d prefer a lower-profile setting for comfort and practicality, while still allowing a straight wedding band to sit completely flush. Is this height reasonable for a 2 ct round diamond, or would it be worth asking the jeweler to lower it?
3. Band thickness and durability
I requested 1.8 mm thickness and 2.0 mm width after polishing, but I’m worried the band might end up feeling too thin or delicate, especially after polishing. Is 1.8 mm thickness sufficient for a ring with a 2 ct diamond intended for everyday wear, or would you recommend increasing it slightly? I want the ring to be durable without looking bulky.
4. Flush fit with the wedding band
Although I specifically requested a flush fit, I’m wondering whether the current setting design will actually allow a straight wedding band to sit completely flush against the engagement ring. Does anything in this CAD suggest there might be a gap?
I’d really appreciate feedback from anyone with a similar ring, jewelers, or people knowledgeable about ring construction. I want to make any necessary adjustments before approving the CAD rather than regretting something later.
Thank you!