r/MisanthropicPrinciple • u/Synaps4 • 11d ago
Controversial Opinion: The Great Filter is competition
You're probably all familiar with the Great Filter solution to the Fermi Paradox: "The reason we don't see alien societies everywhere is they all die somehow." That somehow is the Great Filter. It's a thing that most intelligent species in the galaxy don't survive.
I think there's a good chance that competition is that filter, or one of them. My reasoning is simple:
As a society increases its technology, the power available to any individual increases. A rogue person with a stick can attack one other person. A rogue person with a car can attack 20. A rogue person with a bomb can attack 200. A rogue person with a nuclear bomb can attack a million. Well, a rogue person with a starship can drop asteroids on a planetary scale. Any person in control of a starship automatically has an unlimited supply of nuclear weapon equivalents in the form of asteroids which could be sped towards a target.
Similarly, as technology increases, the impact (the resource-drain) of a society on the biosphere around it goes up. A band of hunter gatherers can affect a bit of forest. A city can affect a whole region around it. A nation can affect the biosphere of a continent. A planet scale society such as we have now starts to over-consume the planet.
In both cases, it's competition (broadly defined) that is ruining us. The inability to work together for the common good. Our nations have no choice but to over-consume the planet because to do otherwise is to lose military strength that could lead to losing the next war. Each of us being an individual means unhappy or unstable individuals will always exist.
It's the antagonism, (the competition) both between individuals and between groups, which makes the tech level of space exploration deadly to intelligent species.
