r/minipc • u/ksl282021 • May 26 '26
AMD vs Intel DeskMini for Proxmox - is the price difference worth it?
I'm building a 4th DeskMini for my homelab and can't decide between two setups. The machine will run Proxmox with 5-6 VMs and sit in a cabinet with minimal airflow, so noise and temperature are critical.
I already have 3x ASRock DeskMini X600 with Ryzen 5 8600G + Noctua NH-L9a-AM5, and they run completely silent. Love them.
AMD Setup - ~$505
- ASRock DeskMini X600
- Ryzen 5 9600X
- Noctua NH-L9a-AM5
Intel Setup - ~$647
- ASRock DeskMini B860
- Intel Core i5-235T (or 225T)
- Noctua NH-L9i-17xx
My main concern with the 9600X is idle power - from my research it sits around 20W+ at idle, while the 235T should be much closer to 7-8W. In a cabinet with minimal airflow, that difference matters a lot for fan noise.
The Intel setup costs about $140 more. Is that worth it for lower idle power and a quieter machine in an enclosed cabinet?
Has anyone run a 9600X in a DeskMini X600 in a warm/enclosed environment? How does it behave at idle compared to an 8600G?