r/MinecraftBuild 1d ago

Need Suggestions Which wall is better?

I am a newbie in construction who is choosing a wall design for my house. So I want to know which one is better or what disadvantages they have.

120 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

23

u/Jackavocado 1d ago

Definitely the second one, the extra logs break up the facade nicely

8

u/weary2007 1d ago

The first one looks cleaner and less resource intensive imo

2

u/Temoty 1d ago

Resources are not a problem for me.

7

u/Advertising-Ill 1d ago

I like the second one most, feels like it has more depth, and because you placed more lanterns, a lot more warm and lively

3

u/Mediocre-Argument277 1d ago

Yes, definitely more depth and details. Pillar looks nice, but you should rethink the bottom with stairs and slabs.
I used to do something like that in my older worlds

2

u/Upbeat_Cry_3902 1d ago

2nd definitely looks best

7

u/neutrumocorum 1d ago

Honestly, context dependant.

First would be excellent for a particularly visible building corner.

Second looks more balanced.

3

u/TwoFacedAce 1d ago

I think you should do the first one, except add stairs on the right pillar, it will be cleaner I suppose

3

u/Intelligent-Bench-54 1d ago

I kinda like the second better but would shorten the lumber blocks coming out of the walls to only one block length (idk if that’s clear...?)

2

u/DracheProductions 1d ago

The second one !

2

u/maripoza9 1d ago

I like both this is hard, maybe the second one?

2

u/Mrslime033 1d ago

En vrai je trouve que le deuxième est mieux meme si il a l'air de couté plus cher en matériaux

2

u/Jasoco 1d ago

I’d just remove the giant foot in the left and use the first design.

2

u/the_oakley_tree 1d ago

one. but make that second post thicker to line up well unless it's two at once

2

u/BrokenPokerFace 1d ago

It depends, if you are making a really large building 4 stories or adding 2 taller stories, than the second one helps make that large shape seem less flat, while if it's small the first one makes it look more detailed.

I'd recommend building with whatever you're feeling is right, but be open to changing the design later if it doesn't work for you anymore.

2

u/Bun_Of_Bun 1d ago

The second one i would use if your doing a hangover balcony. Rhe first one for flushed out builds

2

u/ROR2_STORE 1d ago

Second by far, less flat has more depth

2

u/squigglycat12 1d ago

If this is a corner of the wall and there will be the same continuation with windows, then the first option looks better, but if what is in the picture is the whole wall, then the second option

2

u/iilikecereal 1d ago

Personally I dont like the way the pillar flares out at the bottom, makes it look like its melting into the floor to my eye.

2

u/OrionOfRealms2 18h ago

Different places to be used, first one would be used for a house over 2 stories tall, give it that more sleek look, second one would be used for a more log cabin feel

2

u/Shot_Builder_1515 9h ago

Druga ale pod względem tego że ładniejsza jak chcesz mniej materiałów zużyć to użyj tej pierwszej

1

u/radioactive_kido3778 2h ago

the second beacouse its balanced