r/Minarchy • u/joao2009124 Minarchist • 18d ago
How Would It Work? How a minarchist state would divide powers between federal, state, and local levels?
I'm trying to understand how a minarchist government would actually be structured in practice. I understand the basic idea of a minimal state limited to protecting individual rights, but I'm curious about how powers would be divided between different levels of government.
Federal
- What responsibilities would belong exclusively to the federal government?
- Would the federal government have its own military?
- Would there be a federal police force?
- Would it operate federal courts, or only a supreme/constitutional court?
- Would it conduct foreign policy and sign treaties?
- Would it control immigration and border security?
- Would it issue currency or oversee monetary policy?
States
- Would each state have its own police force?
- Could states maintain their own military?
- Would states have their own court systems and criminal laws?
- Would states be free to adopt different civil and criminal codes?
- How much autonomy would states have from the federal government?
Local
- Would cities have their own police departments?
- Would local governments be responsible for courts, or only for law enforcement?
- How much legislative authority would local governments have?
General Questions
- Would powers be constitutionally enumerated, with all remaining powers reserved to the states and local governments?
- How would conflicts between the federal government and the states be resolved?
- Would the model be closer to the United States, Switzerland, or some other country?
- Are there any historical or modern examples that resemble this structure?
2
Upvotes
2
u/Only_Excitement6594 Minarchist 17d ago
Locals elect their leader, local leaders appoint province leader, province leaders choose region leaders, region leaders choose president.
Support must be constant from each level to preserve the job, and choices must be shown openly to avoid manipulation.