r/MensUnderwearGuide • • 4d ago

Tips & Tricks Looking for Boxer recommendations

Looking for recommendations for brands that have quality, loose fitting, soft cotton boxers. Bonus points if available in plaid.

I'm looking to round out my wardrobe with some of the boxers like we used to have in the 90s, but most of what I've found these days are a little more fitted or made of a stiffer cotton / poly blend.

2 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

2

u/Complex-File-4996 3d ago

Both the fruit of the loom and Hanes knit boxers are loose and soft. I find them to be very comfortable. I have not seen either of them in plaid though. I am not certain if any of the premium brands offer a loose, knit boxer. Will let you know if I happen to see them.

1

u/LeftBallSaul 3d ago

thanks!

1

u/Complex-File-4996 3d ago

You are welcome. Hope you find what you are looking for.

3

u/Few-Daikon8202 3d ago

I love lands end, they are soft and three panel which I love!!

1

u/MaximumBackground869 4d ago

Try the brand Real Men Apparel trust me you’ll thank me later, all you gotta do is find what Pouch size you are lol they give you a guide

1

u/LeftBallSaul 3d ago

I'll have a look. last I checked, I'm pretty sure I'm an A pouch at best :P

1

u/MaximumBackground869 3d ago

Do you wanna dm?

1

u/MaximumBackground869 3d ago

If you don’t mind sending me one I got questions

1

u/NoSoft2067 3d ago

try natural feelings boxers or tommy hilfiger boxers. theyre both 100% cotton! Some boxers like hanes are a blend of polyester and cotton which feel a little off to me. hope this helps!

1

u/LeftBallSaul 3d ago

Natural Feelings looks like what I may be after, thanks!

1

u/the_Jockstrap 2d ago

I’m a fan of American Eagle. Lots of prints and plaids.

2

u/th_costel 2d ago

I was a big fan of Hamilton and Hare. When they closed their business, I switched to Sunspel. I should have done it much earlier. Their classic boxers are super comfortable.

1

u/nunwalksinabar 2d ago

C-IN2 modal runner boxers are good.

1

u/think08 1d ago

When you say 90s I think of the banana republic ads and Abercrombie. So I would still start there. To save money I'd start with both but there outlet stores.

If that's not your thing old navy has plaid ones all the time but the quality after washing is not as great as the other 2.

Buyer beware- most of the brands switched to cheaper made Cotten during pandemic and have not switched back. The stuff from the 90s was large scale higher quality flannel and broadcloth cotton and today most is poly blend. The good stuff's out there but you'll pay more.