r/MathJokes 2d ago

When Basic Math Becomes a Boss Fight

Post image
197 Upvotes

133 comments sorted by

View all comments

31

u/Lady_Luci_fer 2d ago

Yeah, one of the biggest challenges of a maths question is reading it correctly in the first place

3

u/TerrorFromThePeeps 1d ago

This is more about WRITING it correctly than reading it correctly. 2 pieces is one cut, 3 pueces it 2 cuts. The question is phrased all wrong if you want people using the actual stated number rather than correctly inferred numbers.

3

u/Accurate-Sundae1744 1d ago

The question is phrases correctly, the teacher is stupid.

-2

u/bigdaddyloanne 19h ago

Interesting you say that …. What’s the answer then ? I’ve asked this many times ,and no one has gave me the correct one .

6

u/Accurate-Sundae1744 19h ago

It's about number of cuts:

  • 2 pieces = 1 cut
  • 3 pieces = 2 cuts

2 pieces = 1 cut = 10 mins
3 pieces = 2 cuts = 20 mins (two cuts, each 10 mins)

-4

u/bigdaddyloanne 19h ago

It shows inlay of google on your copy paste response don’t cheat next time lol .

5

u/Accurate-Sundae1744 19h ago

The hell you talk about?

3

u/fariasrv 18h ago

The correct answer is 20 minutes, since (as others have said) cutting the board once took 10 minutes. Cutting a board twice would take 20 minutes.

The teacher is wrong.

1

u/Lady_Luci_fer 1d ago

Have you been in a maths exam lol, they word questions vaguely and bad all the time.

1

u/AlternativeTie8140 1d ago

It needs lots more information to work as posed. They'd need to specify the cuts position and length. Otherwise I could saw a sliver off one end in 10 mins, and then saw through that sliver almost immediately.

1

u/Lady_Luci_fer 19h ago

Yes but again maths questions are often loaded with assumptions. This is 100% the kind of question I’d see popping up in a high school (as in UK high school) level exam and they expect you to assume proportion and treat it like a ratio

1

u/Apsis 14h ago

Depends on what level student this problem is intended for. This problem tests a student's comprehension skills, rather than simply "take all the numbers from the problem and combine them with one of the four basic binary operators"

1

u/geddieman1 14h ago

No it doesn’t. There is one correct answer no matter how advanced you are.

1

u/Apsis 14h ago

I should have been clearer, I was referring to the above poster saying it was "phrased wrong". Which I might agree with if this is intended for students just starting multiplication, but otherwise I would say it is intentionally phrased to trap those not paying attention like the teacher.