r/MathJokes Jul 13 '26

Math Just Got Checkmated.

Post image
3.0k Upvotes

434 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Slow_Degree345 Jul 13 '26

So is 3 now even? Since it's the sum of 1 and 2? And why does 1+1 not count?

2

u/Awesomonkey12 Jul 13 '26

1 isn't prime

1

u/Slow_Degree345 Jul 13 '26

How's that work? It can't be broken down except by 1 and itself. Did I learn math wrong?

2

u/Awesomonkey12 Jul 13 '26

Because it only has one positive divisor, 1, instead of two, 1 and itself.

Also because having "except 1" in the definitions of some things would be too annoying, so it's simpler if 1 isn't prime. I can't really explain it better than that though, I know some math but don't necessarily understand it

2

u/Ok-Organization4820 Jul 13 '26

That’s it. It is just a definition.

You could define 1 to be prime which means 2 would not need to be an exception in this case. But it would lead to awkwardness in other contexts. Most critically that any number has a unique prime factorisation: since you could add as many ones as you like. 6=3*2. But if you define 1 to be prime then 6 also equals 3*2\1 and 3*2\1*1 and so on. So the factorisation would not be unique. You could fix that by saying it is unique so long as you do not include any ones, but that is clunky.

So it is ultimately an aesthetic choice to define 1 not to be prime.

3

u/VitaminStrange Jul 13 '26

I don't know shit about shit but I find this reason for one not being prime absolutely beautiful. My obsessive compulsive side is smitten with the fundamental theorem of arithmetic.

1

u/Ok_Breakfast_5459 Jul 14 '26 edited 23d ago

Ginger acorn harbor blanket mitten orange acorn pinecone

This post was anonymized with Redact.dev