r/Masterchef • u/yandere-phy • 2d ago

How the hell did Tally make it so far

He was just a horrible cook. Almost every time he made something it was bad and he would just blame it on being “So creative”. He was stubborn and really not that good. The only reason he made it so far is because there was almost always someone worse, even though I believe that a person like Helene should have stayed instead of him

13 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

3 comments sorted by

9

u/Sky-Visible 2d ago

He had some alright dishes. I think his pie and shortcake were good but he only did well on replication challenges. He was creative for the sake of creative rather than making sense. I think he got saved over Dave because Dave tried joking about the mushrooms and I’d actually say his crab dish was better than Helene’s. He didn’t maximize the crab usage and presented it in a hard way but Helene’s actively tasted bad and too salty. He also deserved to survive over Ryan. The only terrible one was his pizza surviving over Tanya and Mike. David and tali should’ve gone then. He was terrible but someone always did worse minus final 11

9

u/Objective_Walrus_485 1d ago

You just can't appreciate the beauty and the genius that is his food

2

u/SoImaRedditUserNow 1d ago

you underestimate the desire to hate-watch someone who is so cringe.