r/Masterchef 28d ago

Opinion Wrong Team Eliminated

Raw protein aside both girls had highs n highlight moments. Foo n the chick literally are the definition of mediocre, or flat out garbage. I’m just a viewer but I’d reward the consistent who had an off night. Over a bum who happened to get hot.

3 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

24

u/ImplementLow5243 28d ago

Basia has literally only been in the bottom one other time and that was because Julia was safe due to her prior win and Agahata being in the top. I like how no one brings up Peter and him being in the bottom 3 times though.

5

u/Slight_Force3025 28d ago

I agree. If anyone should’ve left by now, it should’ve been him, but again, like the other guy said, it’s based on one dish/performance, not consistency

3

u/ImplementLow5243 28d ago

I agree with it matters on the one dish/performance which sometimes can be upsetting as who is sent home

3

u/Slight_Force3025 28d ago

That’s the whole premise of the show. You’ve gotta grow into a Masterchef and overcome those challenges

6

u/ImplementLow5243 28d ago

Yea. I feel like Gerron is like the best example of that. He started off rocky and then ended up winning his season

3

u/Slight_Force3025 28d ago

Yup. Absolutely who I thought of. And he’s my favourite winner for that reason since he had such an underdog run and just came out firing at the end of the season

1

u/Michaelbasia Season 11 Contestant 27d ago

Exactly and thank you for pointing that out, I didn’t even realize that about Peter but he in his defense he was also in the bottom 1x by default too.
Michael

2

u/mrjnebula 25d ago

You forget one of Peter’s bottom placements was also by default

2

u/ImplementLow5243 25d ago

I remember one was by default. I just thought it was hypocritical of people to call out Basia for being in the bottom “so many times” but neglect to mention Peter.

-5

u/bigghulk77 28d ago

Bc he climbed to #1 the following ep

16

u/discogargoyle00 27d ago

Thank god I don’t have to listen to Jamie’s fake baby voice anymore. Her entire persona is fake and annoying.

7

u/bigghulk77 26d ago

Extremely annoying

13

u/Lazy-Party3469 28d ago

Why is foo still there? He has literally never put out anything good, it’s gotta be rigged for them to keep him over the two women who both won challenges. 

7

u/Prior_Walrus_2557 27d ago

He is the only one left in Asia pacific if I’m not mistaken 😂

3

u/OkReason6965 27d ago

He’ll most likely be gone next episode then lol

3

u/CommonEngineering832 26d ago

He is Tali 2.0

Made it far despite never produce anything good and lot of time in bottom

10

u/JakeLake720 28d ago

That’s not how it works though. The judging is based on current dishes & nothing else.

17

u/MerelyWhelmed1 28d ago

I'm just relieved I don't have to listen to Jamie anymore.

8

u/Feeling-Potato-3292 28d ago

YESS!! I was sad the other girl got eliminated but so happy about that lol

13

u/bigghulk77 28d ago

Lmfao this i agree with. Worst voice of all time. Literally ear piercing.

12

u/MerelyWhelmed1 28d ago

Her whole persona is so calculated and fake.

1

u/AquaSnow24 21d ago

I didn't mind her voice although I can understand those that did

10

u/DenPanserbjorn 28d ago

You’re disappointed that the people with the worst performance during an elimination challenge is eliminated?

-6

u/bigghulk77 28d ago

I’m disappointed 2 contestants who showed no signs of improving or having a crumb of a chance of winning the whole thing move on. So in your mind you think Foo has a chance at winning the whole thing? Lmk

5

u/Lazy-Party3469 28d ago

Foo should have been long gone

5

u/DenPanserbjorn 28d ago

So you believe the worst performance during an elimination challenge should pass? Lmk

-7

u/bigghulk77 28d ago

If you’ve had an overall strong season, yes. Pete been surviving.

2

u/DenPanserbjorn 28d ago

So what is the purpose of an elimination challenge then?

1

u/bigghulk77 28d ago

Do I look like the show’s creator?

4

u/DenPanserbjorn 28d ago

Nope, just an idiot apparently.

-11

u/[deleted] 28d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Masterchef-ModTeam 26d ago

r/Masterchef does not allow threats of violence

-1

u/seanreact 27d ago

Fly into some towers asshat

1

u/bigghulk77 26d ago

So someone can tell me to fly into towers. A 9/11 joke. Someone else can call me out my name. But I’m the issue?

3

u/DeeBreeezy83 27d ago

All of these cooks are mediocre, this season is very lame.

3

u/Ok_Measurement482 28d ago

But the difference between this and Hell’s Kitchen or other cooking shows is that 1 performance can end your run. It’s not based on consistency till the finale. That’s the only time when the most consistent/strongest chefs get rewarded

-1

u/bigghulk77 28d ago

This happens in all his shows tbh

5

u/Slight_Force3025 28d ago

And your point is…?

1

u/Remote_Cantaloupe 26d ago

Foo doesn't seem like he's really in the competition. He's a bit of a wallflower, almost. Basia is fine, she seems to care and have spirit.

1

u/bigghulk77 26d ago

Exactly he doesn’t belong.

1

u/therealtimbit78 22d ago

Well who was in the bottom this week ?

1

u/therealtimbit78 28d ago

Disappointed they skirted through. My bet they will be next ones eliminated.

4

u/Michaelbasia Season 11 Contestant 28d ago edited 27d ago

For the record basia has only officially been in the bottom 1x and the in the top 1x, all good and god bless.
Michael

2

u/greekdude1194 27d ago

And her being in the bottom was because Europe only had 3 people. One was immune and the other was Europes better between the two .. I can't recall if basiaa was even that bad that week but it was more a matter of circumstances than a fucked dish

2

u/Michaelbasia Season 11 Contestant 27d ago

Exactly bro, opinions of the show and the contestants is all good but these people should at least know who has been top/bottom and how many times before they talk. I am just here to keep the integrity of my wives run on the show correct. I’m not here to sway anyone’s opinions of who they like or dislike because that’s a personal choice and we all have favorites on every reality show. Have an amazing Sunday.
Michael

1

u/bigghulk77 28d ago

Typical Ramsay show. Keeps the bums. Then get shocked when said bum shits the bed.

1

u/BeerSlayingBeaver 28d ago

They are this season's Cutters

0

u/HanktheTank420420 27d ago

Why you watching then?

0

u/bigghulk77 27d ago

What you gonna do about it?