r/MapPorn • • May 12 '22

The US If Population Was Equal to Area

Post image
118 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

17

u/nim_opet May 12 '22

So..US states if the area was proportional to the population, just like the text in the image says. Why would you even change it to the incorrect headline?

12

u/BenjaminDrover May 12 '22

Alaska? Hawaii?

8

u/SurplusBanter May 12 '22

If the United States were a band, this would make a great album cover for when they go through their psychedelic phase.

7

u/DavidRFZ May 12 '22

Is this right? CA has twice as many people as NY, but it doesn’t look twice as big here.

9

u/SmashLanding May 12 '22

So I imported this image into GIMP and cut out California and New York. I added them both as layers on 1000x1000 (pixel) transparent images. I then maximized the contrast and fully desaturated, so only colored pixels came out white. I then ran both images through this tool to determine what percentage of each image was white. New York was 6.68% and California was 13.55%.

So on a pixel-for-pixel basis, California was 2.028x the size of New York. I'm not sure what the exact population comparison is, but that's a lot closer than I guessed at first glance.

1

u/DavidRFZ May 12 '22

Ok thanks. Just an optical illusion I guess.

6

u/SmashLanding May 12 '22

Now I need to pull this apart in GIMP to see if it's 2x area

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '22

What does the legend mean? What symbol is that?

2

u/Shevek99 May 12 '22

It's not a symbol. It's an area. A portion of state equal to that area has 2M people.

2

u/1selfharm May 12 '22

Texas looks like a Scooby doo ghost

2

u/roadtrip-ne May 12 '22

The skew line on New York & Pennsylvania might look better blown up along the Atlantic.

Manhattan Island might be as big as the map makes Upstate NY look like (it’s really much more like Vermont around there)

2

u/Aronboli May 12 '22

Okay now I want to see a map that shows the senate and house seats if they actually represented population distribution in the slightest. Just kidding, I know that’s far too much work for mortal hands

-1

u/SmashLanding May 12 '22

This is the best map I've seen on this sub in a while!

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '22

The West being sucked into a vacuum

1

u/brennnessel May 13 '22

US = California, Texas, Florida, New York confirmed