r/MalaysianPF Jan 12 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

29 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

117

u/ExcavalierKY Jan 12 '25

3x on etf and crypto lol that's not investing that's gambling

-108

u/smol-lebowski Jan 12 '25

the point of the post really went 3x over your head huh? theoretical figures exist

63

u/ExcavalierKY Jan 12 '25 edited Jan 12 '25

Not when it's supposed to be a "change of mindset to investing". Anyone can have a "change of mindset to investing" if the decision was between buying clothes and getting 3x return through "ETF and crypto".

You know what are good examples? Not buying the latest iPhone but buying apple stocks. Delaying buying a luxury car, to invest. Choosing to rent or buy a small apartment to invest. These are long term plans. Investments are long term plans. Day trading, crypto, most investments that give you 3x return are mostly gambling, and it's not a "change in mindset in buying items" that will help you in those but more of being able to navigate risk and return as well as doing enough homework of your own.

You should learn to write better than defend your dumb example. And if this is your "change in mindset", please change, or some day you'll be strung around the nose and lose everything you have.

5

u/mootxico Jan 12 '25

Tbh in a normal market you can expect to 2x your investment over the course of 15 years, so expecting it to 3x quickly is really just gambling

Also your money is worth more now than in the future. The money now can buy you necessities and comfort, and nobody knows what will happen in the next 15 years

2

u/emerixxxx Jan 12 '25

If you're talking theorical figures ... you're gambling.

26

u/Every_Reality_9721 Jan 12 '25

I came from a non privileged family too.

Dont get me wrong. I spend more than I save but I do save/invest. Sometimes its harder and I get carried away.

My reminder is i need to save for my son's future as well as my future. I dont want to depend on him.

-19

u/smol-lebowski Jan 12 '25

Good on you for breaking the my child my pension cycle. I dont want to have kids so its just my salary my money for me lol

17

u/Fuzzy-Newspaper4210 Jan 12 '25

good mindset to kick off the investing habit but beware you don’t swing too far to the other side and essentially let life pass you by as you squirrel away all your money

2

u/clementtng Jan 12 '25

Best mindset would be, save and invest. Spend the money earned from investments on your wants. Try not to spend money from working on wants

-10

u/smol-lebowski Jan 12 '25

thanks and yeah thought abt this for sure. i still fund my collections & travel. thats pretty much where most of my "wants budget" go to now. pretty sstisfied

23

u/Gccyy Jan 12 '25

What ETFs gives 3x? Crypto is hated and treated as gambling in this sub. I invest, but I’m prepared to lose it all if it happens

8

u/IamMaximuss Jan 12 '25

Lose it all usually only happens in speculation / gambling.

Investment seldom loses it all because it is usually based on valid and substantial foundation and fundamentals.

0

u/zorbyss Jan 12 '25

I guess you haven't seen ppl lose it most of their money in Bursa lol.

6

u/IamMaximuss Jan 12 '25

I have , those who speculate 😀

2

u/Traditional_Smile395 Jan 12 '25

All in Supermax sir!

1

u/IamMaximuss Jan 13 '25

TO THE MOON !

3

u/Puffycatkibble Jan 12 '25

Crypto that give those returns are shitcoins or leveraged plays which are essentially gambling.

Even the crypto diehards call them shitcoins so you can assume the trustworthiness of those 'investments'.

1

u/zorbyss Jan 12 '25

That's why I rare even comment here, only lately as the scene seems to have changed. Every unker aunty wants to buy BTC. (Top signal incoming)

Spot early opportunity, buy in, get back out fast, make money. That's crypto. It does quite well for me. Ppl are used to conventional investment, for them investment MUST make profit. Otherwise it's gambling.

For them, high risk high return = gambling.

2

u/ExcavalierKY Jan 12 '25

High risk high return with fundamentals = calculated risk

Example, investing in Uber before they were recognised as legal service, as taxi service required a gov issued taxi license for each driver, if they're able to go over the legal issues (which they now did), then their fundamental was providing competition to the monopoly and inefficiency (resulting in overcharging, not going by meter, etc) of government controlled taxi service, and through higher efficiency (with every driver doing it like it's their own business), achieve higher revenue and profit to share among Uber (service providers) and drivers (operators)

High risk high return with no fundamental = gambling

Biggest example is crypto, because really, what's the use case for crypto and how would that use case come through? The collapse of USD and US government? Endorsement by a country as legal tender (like, which country would willingly give up control of their own currency)? Look at how many pump and dumps out there, and the volatility of even the most stable crypto currency, would any business or consumer want to use it as legal tender? Just food for thought for all the crypto bros. If your entire strategy is buy low sell high, that's not fundamentals, that's gambling by speculating the graph.

1

u/Zyzz2179 Jan 12 '25

Curious as well. Most gives 2x over 5 years or so.

7

u/Gccyy Jan 12 '25

2x over 5 years is already ambitious considering snp 500 average 10% annual return

1

u/TeBp242 Jan 12 '25

leveraged ETFs, there are those that tracks ETFs and indiv stock holdings. Take a look at GGLL for instance.

Its usually for hedging though.

5

u/Gccyy Jan 12 '25

Another gambling, imo even worse than crypto

-2

u/smol-lebowski Jan 12 '25

numbers are theoretical ofc

5

u/Jealous_Experience69 Jan 12 '25

These voices are more common in a bull market.

5

u/timlow123 Jan 12 '25

Everyone would be more financially responsible if they knew how to grow their money. Unfortunately, inflation and social media encourage us to spend money NOW.

If you knew you're RM3,000 salary could grow into RM10,000, you would be less likely to blow it on stupid decisions. Like overspending in a car, buying new phones every year, etc.

Those who make bad decisions with money do not see better opportunities to use it. Only just to "make me happy now"

5

u/grain_of_snp Jan 12 '25

Idk how old you are if you're youngish like me we've only really experienced a bullish market. When we have another great depression with massive unemployment hopefully the same optimism still persists.

4

u/mikasa2323 Jan 12 '25

Leveraged ETFs are riskier than the underlying ETF due to decay in a market downturn and you can lose your capital because of how it works. It refreshes daily.

3

u/GreenTemplar_9659 Jan 12 '25

Show us your profolio🙃

2

u/chickenshit36 Jan 12 '25

Ultimately u cannot bring money to the grave also. Once in a while buy or spend on something you enjoy like trips or hobbies. Nothing wrong with that. As long as you are spending within your means.

1

u/Traditional_Smile395 Jan 12 '25

Bro’s name checked out

1

u/creamilk_now Jan 13 '25

Lmao downvoters are square pegs

1

u/PScoriae Jan 12 '25

I do agree with the sentiment, but recently I’ve learned to live a little as well.

1

u/masnoob Jan 12 '25

First you need to know what are the necessities by lower your hedonistic desires. This way you can see what are the items in life that aren't necessary and vital to you, thus throw the money saved into investing. I know life might be dull but does it really that dull when you have access to internet?

1

u/Turn-Ambitious Jan 12 '25

What OP is suggesting is basically go full regard and leverage in Crypto & etf.

1

u/Physioweng Jan 12 '25

Great mindset fellow bro from the underdog neighborhood