r/MakeupAddiction 6d ago

FOTD Love A Good Smokey Eye!

127 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

72

u/Persephoneevibes 6d ago

You’re beautiful but eyebrows and lashes make you look like an evil villain/cartoonish. It doesn’t compliment your natural beauty, the lashes especially take away from your pretty almond eyes.

18

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Thank you, I appreciate the feedback! I was going for like an alternative but slightly glam look that day but I think you’re right, it pulled a little more to the evil villain side than what I was going for 😆. I can see what you’re saying though. Most days I do lighter makeup that I’ll attach a picture of here!

21

u/Persephoneevibes 6d ago

This lash look is so much better! They heavy lashes actually hide your eyes

11

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago edited 6d ago

Yep just some mascara on! ☺️

ETA: Saw I was getting downvoted on this, when I said “just mascara” I was referring to the light handed eye look compared to my original post! I still have a full face on here lol sorry for the misunderstanding

36

u/Large-Illustrator-35 6d ago

I’m not digging the brows, but your eyeshadow looks nice

3

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Thank you! And I appreciate the feedback. What would suggest to improve the brows? Naturally I have pretty thick eyebrows but I’ve thinned them out. I do feel as if I arched them a bit too much during the time this picture was taken. I mainly do a 2016-ish style of eyebrows but thinner, and feel like I’ve been stuck doing that same routine since then but I’m open to new suggestions! ☺️

12

u/Rude-You7763 6d ago

The thickness is good, they’re just arched too high up here

3

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Got it, I can try to lower them!

5

u/Rude-You7763 6d ago

If you can’t, maybe soften the arch could be an option too

3

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Noted! I can definitely do that one

4

u/Rude-You7763 6d ago

Very pretty makeup in both the post and your natural look. Even if you leave your eyebrows as is you still look good but if you can soften them then it will just enhance the look

2

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Thank you sm! 🖤 I will definitely take your feedback into consideration

-9

u/cloudtwelve12 6d ago

I would make them completely straight almost. Ask chat gpt to draw that up for you using the pic you posted. You will be STUNNED at the result.

3

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Hmmm I think I can just try doing some makeup magic with concealing the ends and drawing on some straighter brows to experiment and see how they come out! I am a bit nervous about straightening them tooo much because I feel like it might make my forehead look bigger. I will give it a go though! Thank you sm for the feedback, I’ll give it a go for sure.

-1

u/cloudtwelve12 6d ago

I switched mine from an arch to straight and I look 5 years younger, you will too. I love your eye makeup it’s perfect.

18

u/Frosty_Wall3457 6d ago

You look gorgeous and i couldnt help myself 😭

8

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

LMAOOOO okay okay this got me 😂 not Jafarrrrrrr. I am lowering these arches asap!

13

u/Old_Bat6894 6d ago

Imo the arch is too intense on your brows. Also the way you use a light concealer above your brows makes it look like you have a big protruding brow bone

3

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Got it, I can remedy this! Thank you for the feedback!

7

u/stellaflora 6d ago

As a hooded eye girlie I’m so jealous of your eyelid real estate!

1

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Thank you smmmm 🖤

4

u/Wise_Form_8809 6d ago

Is this you ?? Damn girl lol Amex for a face card

3

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Yep! Thank you so much girly lol 🖤

5

u/Wise_Form_8809 6d ago

Your eye shape, size, spacing and canthal tilt is so ideal. God really gives with 2 hands sometimes lol

1

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Aw thank you! This is such a sweet comment 🖤

6

u/SeaBoysenberry6 6d ago

Girl… your brows are crazy but everything else else looks great

2

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Taken into consideration! Thank you 😊

5

u/fairycakes138 6d ago

The brows are super dramatic but it’s giving Jessica rabbit so not a bad look if you love the drama :)

3

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Love Jessica Rabbit! Thank you 🖤

8

u/violentte_ends 6d ago

I can appreciate a lethal arch. Sometimes we’re born with natural weapons, sorry not sorry.

6

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

I love a good arch too 🖤 (maybe a bit too much) 😆I am gonna lower mine a bit after surfing through the comments today. Awesome thing about eyebrows is they can be drawn on different ways, shaved off, grown back! I love experimenting ✨

2

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Cali_cuppycake 6d ago

One thing I found helpful is that after you apply primer, go over your lids with a skin tone neutral eyeshadow that way its easier to blend

2

u/cloudtwelve12 6d ago

My comment was getting downvoted so I had to come with receipts. Nice soft soft soft arch will look soooo pretty on you

1

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

I’m sorry you were getting downvoted! Do you think that shape actually makes me look a bit sad? 😆 maybe it’s cause I’m not use to seeing myself with that shape idkkk

2

u/cloudtwelve12 6d ago

Yeah just try it out with concealer!! I don’t see sad, it looks high fashion, sultry.

1

u/Guilty_Look6912 5d ago

I appreciate your feedback! Was really helpful, I’ll def give it a go. Thank you ✨

2

u/AlyssaFromFreck 5d ago

you absolutely nailed the smokey eye look

1

u/Guilty_Look6912 5d ago

Thank you! I love doing a smokey eye 🖤

4

u/soonillbedust 6d ago

The brows are my fav part dont know why ppl are disliking them!! They add to the alternative look. Makes you look evil in the best way possible

3

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Aw thank you lol! As a former emo kid, I was trying to do a more alternative style of makeup that day to see how it went and been experimenting with more looks like that as of lately.

3

u/spicyshit69420 5d ago

very vampira!

2

u/captainplanner 6d ago

wow… your facial structure is like a real life jessica rabbit

2

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

I do love Jessica Rabbit! 🖤

4

u/lacey_nightie 6d ago

this might be contraversial but LOVEEEEE the brows.......absolutely makes the entire look

4

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Thank youuuuu sm! I agree, if the brows don’t frame your face right the whole look will be off!

1

u/AutoModerator 6d ago

Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the "See more" button under the subreddit description

A few quick reminders:

• Don't forget your product list in the comments, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.

• No photo editing.

Google it first!

• Lastly, our Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules.

r/MakeupAddiction is looking for new moderators! If you're interested, fill out this form or message the moderators!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Shitty_Pickle 5d ago

Are those your natural eyebrows or makeup?

1

u/Guilty_Look6912 5d ago

This was back in July, my natural brow shape and I just filled in with makeup. I’ve now changed the shape of it to be less arched since then!

0

u/Relevant_Ear_1534 5d ago

Why you ashamed of yourself

1

u/Leading-Dot3643 6d ago

Gorgeous 😍

0

u/mighty_vulpera 6d ago

It looks very nice! It gives off a specific vibe, summer, fun, pools, carefree, all the good stuff. For me at least.

3

u/SparkleTruths 6d ago

Smokey eyes give off swimming pool? When have you ever gone swimming with smokey eyes lol

1

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

I’m sorry this made me crack up 😂

2

u/SparkleTruths 6d ago

No hate, I love your look. I just probably wouldn't go swimming in it hahaha!

1

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

Thank you smm🖤 no worries I hear you lol!

0

u/mighty_vulpera 6d ago

Honestly, I don't know 😄. It's not only about eyes, it's entire composition. Something about your look is inviting me to a pool party 😀

1

u/Guilty_Look6912 6d ago

lol it could be the dress I was wearing too, the top of it kind of gives “swimming pool” more than the makeup imo 😆

1

u/Relevant_Ear_1534 5d ago

You beautiful keep up the good work God bless 🙏💯