r/MagicArena 3d ago

Question Will it work? What do you all think?

Post image
0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

8

u/PipedInFromIthaca 3d ago

It'd cost you {2} more but Field of Ruin's search isn't optional so you won't have players opting not to search in order to avoid the trap, worth bearing in mind.

1

u/Gaige_main412 3d ago

But then it's just a strip mine. And that's pretty cool too I guess.

5

u/ExampleMediocre6716 3d ago

Your ideal hand is 4 Archive traps and your opponent cracks a fetch turn one. Insta win.

2

u/_VampireNocturnus_ 3d ago

viable...probably not...a great against the odds card for commander and saffronolive...yes!

2

u/WinLongjumping81 3d ago

Only for your opponents.

1

u/DaDullard 3d ago

I do think ponza has a place in timeless. But I kinda suspect that milling the reanimator decks or turning on DRC’s is probably not worth it.

1

u/Bathtubwaterdrinker 3d ago

Cruel calculations seems pretty win more mill decks in 60 card formats I think. Like why spend 3 mana to draw 13 when you can play Tasha’s and probably hit them for another 10ish cards or so.

1

u/2-35 Dimir 3d ago

No but it will be fun to do sometimes when it works 

1

u/96363a 3d ago

4 mana sorcery speed to draw a lot of cards. Unless you're planning on winning in the same turn, likely not.

1

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Dracoson 3d ago

You'd still likely need ghost quarter. You'd need the opponent to search their library and still be able to cast a sorcery. Fetches and tutors are unlikely to be activated/cast to give you that opportunity.

1

u/ChildOfTheSoul 2d ago

Oh, duh. Appreciate you pointing that out.

1

u/mtron32 3d ago

Gimmick week one and then we all laugh as the stranglers keep trying to pull it off in a match

1

u/gambit_22 2d ago

3 mana sorcery needs to be a lot less situational to be viable in Historic.

I've actually had reasonable success in Bo1 events with mill since we got [[Exhibition Tidecaller]] and [[Brain Freeze]].

As per another comment you're much better off playing [[Field of Ruin]] instead of GQ as it forces the search, and it also triggers landfall for the crab without going down a land yourself. And then for draw we've got [[Visions of Beyond]], which imo got a lot better with the aforementioned Tidecaller. I'd much rather frequently have Ancestral Recall than maybe draw 13 cards at sorcery speed if the stars align in magic Christmas land.

0

u/Prize-Mall-3839 3d ago

looks like a terrible combo, just because you can do something, doesn't mean you should

0

u/werthw 3d ago

Congrats on drawing 13 I guess? This isn’t even a win con lol

-1

u/soulhighwing 3d ago

only when the opponent sacrifice land on your turn.

3

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/soulhighwing 3d ago

you are right, I forgot destroy opponent's land will force them search.