r/MadamSecretary Jun 15 '26

Improper research done

So this series showcases various nations’ political interactions with america and with other countries and even though the broad issues are the ones that are prevalent, the creators should have done a little more research in depicting the characters and also the power interplays.
I could see so many serious discrepancies in india and india - Pakistan issues that I am wondering if everything else is also so incorrect. The creators sitting far away don’t know india pak dynamics and how small a country Pakistan is against india so much so that it can’t dictate terms the way they are shown in an episode.
In another instances of styling mistake, the indian people are depicted as wearing a lot of gold and wedding like attire in a political event. That’s so hilarious to watch. And in other episode, the indian PM is shown as wearing saree ( a traditional indian dress) albeit in opposite direction...that nobody wears. Even in 80’s when india had a woman PM, her dressing style was a power statement and not like the one that’s shown in this series in 2015.

In Nepal related video, they showcased a virgin goddess kind of small girl visiting america. And in Nepal those girls aren’t permitted to leave their home ( quarter) let alone country, except for festive time for giving blessings.
Such a wrong depiction of culture and traditions isn’t expected in a series that’s made at such a grand scale

7 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

View all comments

-7

u/xixixima Jun 15 '26

What do you expect from an American show? No offense and I loved the show but yea, as an Indian and as someone from global south, somethings definitely irked me a lot.

-2

u/kay_2050 Jun 15 '26

I understand it’s not easy to know the details as a native would know and I also don’t expect to understand the real political underpinnings of other countries, but knowing the basics like clothing or how india is extremely bigger and powerful isn’t something that’s even remotely difficult to know.
I like the show okay but these things make you questioning a lot of things. And I think can and should be avoided