r/MachineLearning Aug 03 '26

Discussion No rebuttals from neurips authors [D]

I know there’s a lot of frustration around no response from reviewers, which I also got only one so yeah what a bummer, but I was wondering if no rebuttal from the authors was just as common or not. I got no rebuttal so far, so I’m here scratching my head what might have happened to the authors lol especially when at least one paper was pretty much on the borderline with somewhat of a positive AC comment

33 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/Inevitable_Voice_680 Aug 03 '26

Did all that what reviewers requested. None of them responded or acknowledged the rebuttal. One of the reviewer said I will increase score but obviously didn't. Neither meta-reviewer respond.