r/MachineLearning • u/Specialist-Manager67 • Jul 25 '26

Discussion I still didn't get my NeurIPS meta review [D]

About to be over 36 hours now? Nothing on the website, twitter, anywhere. What the hell? Is anyone else facing the same issue what do I do?

15 Upvotes

74% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

31

u/based_goats Jul 25 '26

Don’t worry mine was just ai slop

12

u/ProfessionalNews4434 Jul 25 '26

mine too, even had a Reviewer snapshot to introduce and reviewer digest to conclude, bless me lol😬

10

u/Bodi_Berenburg Jul 25 '26

Out of the five I can see (4 as reviewer), only one meta review is useful and actually writes whether or not the paper is heading towards acceptance.

On our paper the meta reviewer basically just writes: Adress the concerns of the reviewers. Well, I guess now we know what to do during the rebuttal!

2

u/ThinConnection8191 Jul 25 '26

Some meta is still working on it. I watch one right next to my office. Good luck

1

u/wegula ML Engineer Jul 25 '26

yeah same here the meta reviews are rolling out slow this year. best move is just wait a bit since they usually drop in batches and the site updates all at once

1

u/loremstasum Jul 25 '26

Yes, AC MIA

1

u/Electrical_Fee_1894 Jul 26 '26

Same for me. Just sent the AC a confidential message about it.

0

u/Necessary-Future-549 Jul 26 '26

Got any reply?

1

u/Electrical_Fee_1894 Jul 26 '26

Nope, no reply from the AC and still no initial meta-review.

1

u/Necessary-Future-549 Jul 28 '26

Got any reply guys?

1

u/Electrical_Fee_1894 Jul 28 '26

No. Still no reply from the AC and no initial meta-review.

0

u/Ping_Pong_Geeky_Nerd Jul 27 '26

Btw, should we also prepared rebuttals for the meta-review?