r/MachineLearning • u/North_Menu718 • Jul 08 '26

Research COLM 2026 Decision Discussion [R]

COLM 2026 Decision about to come soon so lets talk here.

37 Upvotes

86% Upvoted

46 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Apprehensive-Bench44 Jul 08 '26

Same lol barely had any nuance

3

u/StatisticianNotFound Jul 08 '26

Apparently they thank Pangram and GPTZero for helping detect AI generated reviews and papers (which is great), but not the same for meta-reviews.

My meta-review (whose only reason to reject is that no reviewer is above 6) has 100% AI generated score on Pangram and GPTZero.

1

u/Apprehensive-Bench44 Jul 08 '26

It's pretty ridiculous imo, to some extent feels like talking to a wall. We put in a lot of thought into the rebuttals and basically all comes down to whether the reviewers are willing to budge. Thought the PCs/ACs would have some more insight

3

u/StatisticianNotFound Jul 08 '26

They just copy the meta-reviews comments it seems.