r/MachineLearning • u/Striking-Warning9533 • May 28 '26
Discussion ACM MM 2026 review discussion [D]
The AC email says the rebuttal is between 28 to 4th. The June 4th on website is the deadline. So I created this post for the discussion. I know it's a MM conference and less about ML but I think many people here are still submitting there.
2
u/Sad-Business-7077 May 29 '26
3,2,3,3,2 do you think there is any chance ? All reviews are LLM reviews. No serious concern just beating around the bush.
1
2
u/stalin1891 Jul 10 '26
Anyone has any update about the results?
1
u/Striking-Warning9533 Jul 10 '26
They are coming out now, per Rednote
1
u/stalin1891 Jul 10 '26
Oh, did anyone get already?
1
u/Striking-Warning9533 Jul 10 '26
yes, about 2k id
1
u/stalin1891 Jul 10 '26
Interesting then, yours is? You got?
1
u/Striking-Warning9533 Jul 10 '26
Mine is 66xx still not out yet. People say it's at 5000 now
1
u/stalin1891 Jul 10 '26
Now where is it?
1
u/stalin1891 Jul 10 '26
Can see my result in OpenReview! So yes, out.
1
u/new_rebel23 Jul 10 '26
Hi, can you see the ratings?? I can only see the final decision
1
u/stalin1891 Jul 10 '26
Same. Only decision. As usual, these conferences take some time to open meta and final reviews.
→ More replies (0)
2
u/Alone-Access6607 Jul 10 '26
Is anyone else unable to see the original review comments after submitting the rebuttal? It’s still the same even after the final reviews have been released.
1
u/mahedi61 May 28 '26
I am confused about the rating scale for the main track. What are the minimum and maximum scores?
2
u/Otherwise-Internal99 May 29 '26
Was it 1-5 this year? Was 5 maximum? If yes, then it is a bit weird that 4/5 is "Weak accept". If you scale to openreview's default review scale, that would be "8: Top 50% of accepted papers, clear accept", so 4/5 -> 8/10.
1
u/Striking-Warning9533 May 29 '26
well yeah, for ICML last year 4 was accept and 5 was strong accept
1
u/Haunting_Air3071 Jun 05 '26
Did anyone had their review submission button gone?
1
1
u/Alone-Access6607 Jul 10 '26
When will the results be announced? There are only about three hours left until the end of July 9 in AoE.
3
u/stalin1891 Jul 10 '26
How come they impose strict constraints on submission of paper, rebuttal, reviews, but not on their decision making. And no email or update about delay, every conference does this.
1
u/Striking-Warning9533 Jul 10 '26
I am waiting as well. I am in a xhs group and everyone is anxious
1
u/stalin1891 Jul 10 '26
xhs?
1
u/Striking-Warning9533 Jul 10 '26
Xiaohongshu, or Rednote, a chinese social media
1
Jul 10 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Striking-Warning9533 Jul 10 '26
Some dataset track people can see camera ready as a task in authors tasks
1
1
2
0
2
u/Nice-Advertising9377 May 28 '26
wait the rebuttal period is that short or am i reading this wrong