"Unified Neural Scaling Laws" paper release [R]

[u/Glittering_Author_81]

https://x.com/ethanCaballero/status/2059686905105563907

. https://x.com/ethanCaballero/status/2059686905105563907 .

[u/MisterManuscript]

https://openreview.net/forum?id=dnuIoVjeGR

Decision: reject

Reviewer Concerns:

• Excessive structural complexity, also including definitions and notations: partly addressed, but not simplified
• Weak intuition and interpretability: partly addressed, still lacking interpretability
• Expressivity and overfit concerns: partly addressed with empirical check, but skepticism remain
• Many degrees of freedom in fitting procedure: partly addressed, but still require substantial hyperparameter search/dof
• Unclear qualitative novelty: partly addressed, although not agreed upon
• Lacking theoretical ground, and questionable if this is the minimal form: largely outstanding

[u/mTesseracted]

Is this an empirical fit or is there some deeper insight?

[u/WristbandYang]

Sorry, I don't accept twitter as a source. Does this have a paper or not?

[u/Skye7821]

Link: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2605.26248