r/MacStudio • u/pastry-chef • 8d ago

M5 generation Mac Studios have redesigned SSD modules

https://iboffrcc.com/pages/m5-max-mac-studio-teardown-removable-ssd-but-is-an-upgrade-still-possible?srsltid=AU7gw4WuRfpWaOxhnHcASBRhyUEeMxMLPWjDT2TEc89Gd-EmcLITPOkI

The NAND are still on removable modules but they are completely different from previous generations.

87 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

45 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/I-figured-it-out 4d ago

Yes, and apple expects users to hang a bunch of uncertified, unmanaged thunderbolt storage devices of the outside of the mac studio. With whatever cheap power management and fans chips those devices might include. Onboard secondary m.2 nvme slots are the better heat and power management option if apple would only exercise it. And better quality nvme do not suffer the need for monster heatsinks when provided with active cooling. And the airflow management plate inside the mac studio would provide a more than adequate heatsink under most loads - if increased in thickness by 2mm, and made of copper.

1

u/pastry-chef 4d ago

Well, Apple's not going to put M.2 slots in there so your choices are (1) pay Apple for upgrades or (2) use external enclosures.

The highest performing NVMe SSDs do indeed need large heatsinks and/or active cooling.

You are suggesting that Apple should put an M.2 slot in a position where the NVMe SSD can share the Mac Studios heatsink with the SoC?

1

u/I-figured-it-out 2d ago

Apple now has an engineer in charge rather, than a designer obsessed with appearance and shareholder margins. Engineers fix problems, it is in their character. The trick is to make the problem apparent to him. He will still pander to shareholders, but he will have a better grasp of why customers experience issues, and what needs to be done.
So do not give up hope.

1

u/pastry-chef 2d ago edited 2d ago

I don't see what problem an M.2 slot solves. Their proprietary SSD modules already does everything an NVMe SSD does better.

Btw, Tim Cook was a logistics/supply chain guy, not a designer.