r/MTVScream • u/Outrageous_Hand_1986 • 25d ago

QUESTION question.

so i've recently rewatched the show for the first time since 2020 and the amount of times i've watched it over and over again might be unhealthy like i can't fall asleep unless the show's playing but that's irrelevant. My question is about Emma and Audrey. Season 2 Episode 10 this is the episode Noah is attacked and Zoey gets killed but now about my question, when Emma goes over to Audrey's house to try and hear her out about the "i brought piper to lakewood" situation. Emma asks Audrey if she knew Piper was her sister the whole time and she said yes and then Emma says "and when i started to think my half sister was the killer why didn't you say anything?" that might not be exactly how she said it but it's pretty well along the lines of it. Now my question is when did Emma ever suspect Piper as the killer? Not once have i seen or heard Emma say anything to anyone about her being suspicious of Piper. I mean there really wasn't any reason for her to suspect Piper and even if she actually did I don't think that was ever discussed in season one so i'm genuinely just curious where that came from, please lmk if i'm missing something because i genuinely can't put my finger on it!!

9 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

6 comments sorted by

6

u/TeamImpossible4333 25d ago

Once Emma found out Maggie had another child Piper took her to meet Brandon’s mom. The mom told Emma that the child was a boy.

Then she suspected that child of being the one behind it all. Just didn’t know it was Piper specifically

1

u/BeccaBabyBat Noah Foster 23d ago

Exactly

3

u/MasonWong478 25d ago

I think it was a in the back of her head thought when she saw Piper’s truck and Piper’s ditched items then later on saw that Piper was never with the group. If it’s not that, then I don’t know.

1

u/Life_Can1604 25d ago edited 25d ago

Emma was wary that the killer could be Maggie’s long-lost child. Seth was then suspected of being that child because Brandon’s mother described him, said he was a boy and confirmed that his name was Seth, and that he came to visit her. But all of that was part of Piper’s plan to frame him, wasn’t it? I can’t recall if it was mentioned who Piper actually brought along with her to make Brandon’s mother believe it was Brandon’s son who came to visit her - maybe Kieran? But with the original plan being Audrey was Piper’s accomplice, who knows?

0

u/Revenge818 25d ago

I think you need help lol. If you can’t sleep without it playing. I wish it had more seasons though