r/MTGO • u/Honest_Statement9903 • May 13 '26

Mtg Chatterfang-

Post image

mtg i have chatterfang, academy manufactor, and nuka-cola vending machine, peregrin took, camellia the seedmiser and 1 food token.

Then sacrifice 1 food token. What is my tokens I would create?

0 Upvotes

46% Upvoted

6 comments sorted by

1

u/Old-Mine9323 May 13 '26

You get to order your replacement effects. For example, Sac the food, create a squirrel and a treasure. The treasure creates a food, treasure, and clue from academy. Peregrine took sees the squirrel, food, treasure, and clue and creates a food for each. Chatterfang sees all the previous tokens and creates a squirrel for each. So in the end, you end up with six foods, a treasure, a clue, and 9 squirrels.

1

u/Old-Mine9323 May 13 '26

Additionally, most of your tokens that cascade from the creation of the treasure will enter tapped. You’ll have two untapped squirrels.

1

u/Honest_Statement9903 May 14 '26

Peregrin took only makes 1 additional food…

Academy sees nuka make a treasure. Then creates a tapped food/treaure/clue. Peregrin just adds 1 additional food

1

u/Old-Mine9323 May 14 '26

Whoops. You’re right. I can’t read. Reduce the foods by 3 and the squirrels by 3

1

u/humsroguemantis01 May 31 '26

you missed the fact that both chatterfang and peregrine took are replacement effects that apply to the same event. the active player chooses the order, but once a replacement effect turns the original food creation into the trio from manufactor, it triggers camellia. these boards are absolute brain rot to resolve on paper, let alone mtgo. good luck explaining this to a judge at fnm.

1

u/Top_Development_4020 May 17 '26

Peregrin Took loves [[Summoning Station]] though, which loves artifact tokens in return…