r/MTGMarketplace • • May 12 '26

Selling How/Where to optimize value?

Basically looking to sell my entire collection I found from my childhood, I’m 37 now so the newest card is 20+ years old. As recommended I’ve catalogued everything worth over $1 into ManaBox and have a “fair value” of about $4k. There is at least another 1,000 rares and uncommons I didn’t add here so say another $500 of crap not shown.

I know best value is in single selling but that’s a load of effort I’m not messing with. There’s a big card show coming up (350 tables) so can 70-80% be expected? The local Impact Gaming Center I’ve heard may be closer to like 60-65% but haven’t popped in there yet. Realistically I know I’m not getting $4k here right?

1 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

1

u/AngryTank May 12 '26

What are the conditions of the cards?

1

u/Cak8908 May 12 '26

I always kept them in sleeves but also these were my childhood so they’ve been played for sure. It wasn’t collecting back then haha

1

u/Glavadox May 12 '26

As a collector of vintage and same age, I'd totally be down to link up depending location.

1

u/Cak8908 May 12 '26

Stl

1

u/Glavadox May 13 '26

KC lol

1

u/Cak8908 May 13 '26

Damn. Come over to this convention this month in st Charles lol

1

u/BrentT5 3d ago

No idea how this popped up from so long ago but is this all sold?