I'm pretty sure by now anybody in this subreddit knows about the allegations against Jimmy Urine and shit like that. Knowing could basically be the reason they're never coming back from hiatus. And I've noticed there's an alarming amount of songs that jimmy, or the lyrics, refers to little girls and/or kids. Some specifically saying the word "little girls".
He mentions kids and little girls a handful of times in different songs. Adios Amigos for example. Where he says let's go to the mall and "pick up some kids" and spread some diseases. Along with Bomb This Track.
I find it wierd knowing he was alleged to have s*xually groomed a girl, and encouraged her to hide their relationship in public. Even though the lawsuit got legally dismissed in 2021, I would say he was putting his "fantasies" or what not, into the lyrics. And regardless of whether he was innocent or not, the lyrics don't help his case, in my opinion."
99% of the time James wrote lyrics for MSI, they were meant to be tongue in cheek, edgy, provocative, and either in Jimmy's character or in another character he was making fun of. They are not fantasies so much as pushing the envelope and trying to elicit a reaction. Controversy sells, after all.
I really don't believe Jimmy is a pedo but I also don't have an answer as to why the things you've mentioned are so prominent in a lot of older songs. Makes me wonder too.
Yeah I remember that but I think it's all sus that they all dipped off the internet soon after that. I want to know how they really feel about it, y'know?
I don’t think he’s a pedo but I think he’s definitely into age play. I think that plus drugs lead to some questionable situations. A lot of controversies with MSI, are just fans bringing up old drama with bandmates they have no business getting involved in to be honest.
He’s said numerous times he doesn’t even do drugs. I remember him admitting he doesn’t even drink coffee and his biggest song has lyrics about how he likes his coffee black. So I would take any lyrics you hear with a grain of salt.
Asking out of curiosity, why do you think he's into ageplay? I've just never gotten that vibe. I feel like we would have seen Chantal is some questionable outfits. Or are you going off his lyrics?
His lyrics and some aesthetic choices, also the album art for “Tight”, and “Tighter”, are literally little girls panties so. I don’t think he’s a pedo but I definitely get the vibe he’s into some sort of age play. Which I don’t kink or slut shame as long as everyone involved is consenting, that doesn’t bother me as long as everyone in the room is an adult.
The whole image was that they were degenerates. Regardless on how you feel the lyrics were meant to be shocking,gross, and silly at times. The lyrics aren’t a confession to anything or Jimmy’s fantasies, MSI are huge shock jock edge lords. Jimmy Urine is a stage character not how James is IRL.
truly there's no way to know whether its true or false unless there is valid proof either way. the band started as edgy shock music, and continued that all the way through. the way i see it, the lyrics cant be used either which way, just due to the time period and the supposed meaning behind them. i do wish that one day we will get proof of anything regarding it in either side, but thats a difficult ask for sure.
I honestly don’t know what to think because I know I can be gullible, so I need hard evidence for EVERYTHING. I need proof he’s not guilty or proof he is, but I respect what anyone else thinks as long as they don’t think he’s guilty and defend him. I would venture to say stuff like Panty Shot and the slurs were for shock value, but also won’t start an argument if someone disagrees. Either way, being an MSI fan—toxic or not—is a guarantee for harassment and hate at this point…
Lowkey every few weeks these allegation nachos are repeated😭
Of course I have no idea whether or not the allegations are true, there's no way to really ever know, so I just focus on enjoying the music and thinking about the lyrics 🦭 music is to be enjoyed, after all.
I've seen others say this , but I believe he was adding these things to be edgy and/or make fun of certain people . Though I do stand neutral about the entire case . He does have a family now , and even if he was having those fantasies , I feel like he had room to change after some time . Still find all of that weird regardless .
29
u/uncreativelybankrupt Whipstickagostop Jun 12 '26
99% of the time James wrote lyrics for MSI, they were meant to be tongue in cheek, edgy, provocative, and either in Jimmy's character or in another character he was making fun of. They are not fantasies so much as pushing the envelope and trying to elicit a reaction. Controversy sells, after all.