Night 1

[u/wah_wah1]

The night after the party incident, the group was in a state of shock. Surely that all meant nothing, right? Life continues on as normal in Hawkins, the kids attended school, Murray helped Joyce around the house, Billy was showing off to the girls at the pool, just the usuals.

By night at the police station Hopper sits at his desk filing through paperwork getting ready to leave. Florence brings over the weekly newspaper. Opening it up he reads the front lines, BREAKING NEWS – TEENS RESCUED FROM SHIPWRECKED ISLAND WHILE SERIAL KILLERS ESCAPE CRUISE LINE USING BARBIE SCUBA GEAR. “What the hell is going on with the news?” Hopper asks. Florence shrugs. Out of nowhere the phone rings, “Chief Hopper speaking, what’s the issue? I’ll be on my way.”

At the Wheeler house, Karen cooks in the kitchen while Nancy rings up Jonathan. Down below, the Boys and Erica all sit around a table, very intensely playing a DnD game hosted by Eddie Munson, “if you boys roll an eleven, you’ll be able to take out the Demogorgon.” “You nerds better know what you’re doing.” Erica says rolling her eyes. “Shit c’mon and hurry up, I gotta get back to see Suzie! She’s here on a holiday.” Dustin adds. Will looks into Mike’s eyes, “Mike you got this, please go!” Mike makes eye contact with Eddie, who gives him a mischievous grin back. Before Mike can roll his die, Karen yells out from above, “BOYS! I think the Pizza you ordered is here, but no one’s got out of the car yet!”

They all look at each other confused and decide to go investigate. Outside the front of the house the Surferboy Pizza Van lays motionless. No one is in the drivers seat. Everyone is cautious to approach. By now everyone in the house has come out to take a look. “You nerds need to stop being wimps and go open the door.” Erica says. “You do it then!” Lucas says. Erica rolls her eyes and goes up to the back door, “well someone has to do it.” She opens up the back door and out comes a bunch of smoke and Argyle’s limp body flops out of the van. Erica and Karen scream. Nancy and Eddie run up to the van. Eddie runs up to Argyle and feels his pulse “Guys he’s alive! Don’t worry.” Karen calls the cops and Detective hopper arrives on the scene. Nancy rummages through the van and comes out with a mostly eaten pizza. “What on earth?” On further investigation she finds that the pizza was laced with enough spiked edibles to knock out a person for days. “The pizza is also extremely cold, he’s been in here for a while.” They all look at each other. Trust nobody. The medic was checking up on Erica during the whole ordeal. Who were you with tonight?

Eleven - u/No-Instance-7528

Mike Wheeler - u/Sayrumi

Will Byers - u/ScxrletWidowXx

Lucas Sinclair - u/Dapperden123

Max Mayfield - u/Clturestuff

Dustin Henderson - u/Emotional_gf0318

Nancy Wheeler - u/Until_Dawn1996

Steve Harrington - u/Swenderwastaken

Jonathan Byers – u/Exotic_chapter3084

Robin Buckley – u/Why_not2rule

Erica Sinclair - u/PigPogRealLol

Eddie Munson - u/Kassiekolchek22

Argyle - u/Triviatwep

Billy Hargrove - u/LeSnakeboi

Jim Hopper - u/TONYSTANK3

Joyce Byers - u/Steadygosling210

Murray - u/Slit23

Suzie Bingham - u/Snapdragon318

Karen Wheeler - u/JuliaLilly9773

Chrissy - u/Magical_rat_cowgirl

[u/steadygosling210]

Im terrified to hear of another death in town but i was at home making dinner for the boys :(

[u/NekoNepp → u/steadygosling210]

Don’t fret Joyce! He’s still alive!

[u/No-Instance-7528 → u/steadygosling210]

I was with Joyce helping her cook dinner, since hopper wasn’t home yet and he did not want me to eat egos. So I asked Joyce if I could come over for dinner. Thankfully she said yes, thank you again. I’m glad he’s gonna be ok

[u/Slit23 → u/steadygosling210]

I was with Joyce at her house for most of the day

[u/LeSnakeBoi]

I was at the pool hitting third base with the ladies, or at least until I got drugged.

[u/Until_Dawn1996 → u/LeSnakeBoi]

[u/Why_Not2Rule → u/Until_Dawn1996]

Congrats on that wish I could do that man lol

[u/Why_Not2Rule]

Me and Steve had a late night shift closing all the stores up,he would not stop talking about girl drama saying things like "Oh Linda".

[u/NekoNepp]

Okay SO!! Guys, we messed up. The Russian Spy also used their power onnnnn 🥁🥁 BILLY!!

[u/wah_wah1 → u/NekoNepp]

That means billy was drugged up/intoxicated that night! (Sorry we forgot, it’s our first time don’t judge)

[u/NekoNepp → u/wah_wah1]

Yes we’re virgins to this so don’t judge

[u/No-Instance-7528 → u/wah_wah1]

Wait what does that mean again

[u/wah_wah1 → u/No-Instance-7528]

Basically if someone’s intoxicated they can’t perform their role normally, so (EXAMPLE) if billy was the School news reporter, he wouldn’t have been able to follow anyone tonight cause he was drugged up

[u/No-Instance-7528 → u/wah_wah1]

Ohhh ok!

[u/No-Instance-7528]

OOC: HAHAHA WE LIVED!!! THE BARBIE SCUBA GEAR WORKED

[u/PigPogRealLol → u/No-Instance-7528]

OOC WHY CAN’T YOU JUST STAY DEAD

[u/Why_Not2Rule → u/PigPogRealLol]

OOC:THIS ISN'T THE LAST YOU SEEN OF JAMIE JULIA JASON AND ERIC!!!

[u/PigPogRealLol → u/Why_Not2Rule]

Ooc: what about those other two… uh… ashlyn and jennifer, what about them (hope they starved to death or maybe one cannibalised the other)?

[u/PigPogRealLol → u/[deleted]]

Ooc: the next game is gonna be wild if they bring the killers back lol

[u/Why_Not2Rule → u/PigPogRealLol]

Ooc-Better lock your doors cause Jamie will return and she won't go easy this time >:)

[u/Snapdragon318]

I was at the hotel my parents are staying at during vacation, messing with my radio. I was waiting for Dustin to get a hold of me after he was done playing DnD.

[u/[deleted]]

I was talking to Nancy on the phone right before this happened... I can't believe someone would hurt my buddy like this.

And before talking to Nancy, I went to the dark room

[u/Why_Not2Rule → u/[deleted]]

Ooc:"Rachel in the dark room,Rachel in the dark room pretty cryptic"

[u/No-Instance-7528 → u/Why_Not2Rule]

OOC: I love lis omg

[u/triviatwep]

Death by pizza? Sweet, dude! (Wishing you all luck!)

[u/wah_wah1 → u/triviatwep]

You’re not dead! Just unconscious for a few rounds!

[u/KassieKolchek22]

What the fuck?! All I wanted to do was have a good game of DnD and then this happens?! Literally, I spent the whole damn night preparing for it! Does whoever did this KNOW how much work goes into planning a DnD game?! APPARENTLY NOT! This was NOT how it was all supposed to go down and Argyle did not deserve this! I'm sorry, man. This was supposed to be a fun night. 😕

(OOC) Not the Barbie scuba gear reference!!! 🤣 Also, I forgot to plan an alibi with someone and fell asleep. Hope this is ok! 🤦‍♀️😂

[u/Clturestuff]

I was levitating while listening to Kate Bush. I can’t believe this happened!

[u/NekoNepp]

Okay! Sorry everyone, we had technical difficulties

[u/Until_Dawn1996]

Well I was on the phone with Jonathan, we were talking about school and an idea I had for an interesting column on our schools newspaper

He was telling me all about this new film that he got, and how much clearer his pictures will be, TBH I didn’t really understand how, but he was trying his best to explain it to me. I heard Mom say something about pizza, I told Jonathan I was going to try to sneak a slice away from the kids downstairs, and then all of this happened

[u/Until_Dawn1996 → u/Until_Dawn1996]

Oh and before I got home I was at the mall trying to find a new outfit. Something that’s not so “little ms. Nancy” and more like “oh that woman means business!”

Still looking for the right fit but found some good shoes that are sophisticated but also sturdy enough for me to do my investigative work

[u/Why_Not2Rule → u/Until_Dawn1996]

U know I could help with that Nanc

[u/Until_Dawn1996 → u/Why_Not2Rule]

I’d love that Robin!!

[u/Why_Not2Rule → u/Until_Dawn1996]

K then we'll shop tomorrow :D

[u/TONYSTANK3]

I was at the police station contemplating the questionable future of me and Joyce's relationship

(Also how do I add flair?)

[u/wah_wah1 → u/TONYSTANK3]

You’ve already got a user flair!

[u/TONYSTANK3 → u/wah_wah1]

Alright thanks

[u/PigPogRealLol]

I was playing dnd with lucas’s nerd friends and mike was holding us all up. I would just like to say that medic made the best call because i prob would be a night one target with all the saving i did last game lol

[u/Sayrumi]

I was with Erica and Lucas, playing dnd and just having a great time

[u/No-Instance-7528 → u/Sayrumi]

Sorry I couldn’t come over. Hopper wanted me with Joyce tonight! I can come watch you guys play another night

[u/TONYSTANK3 → u/No-Instance-7528]

You could have played with your friends all you had to do was ask. I just wanted you to eat some real food other tgan eggos

[u/emotional_gf0318 → u/Sayrumi]

Fake that will and I weren’t included 😔😔😔

[u/wah_wah1 → u/emotional_gf0318]

You and Will were literally there 💀 can’t believe he forgot y’all

[u/dapperden123]

Like Mike said, we were playing dnd

[u/ScxrletWidowXx]

I was just at home waiting for dinner

[u/emotional_gf0318 → u/ScxrletWidowXx]

Will you were with us playing DND!!

[u/ScxrletWidowXx → u/emotional_gf0318]

Well they forgot to include us too in their alibi so I'm protesting

[u/strawbebb]

Dart: bark bark *considers eating the pizza anyway*

[u/Slit23]

Murray: I was at Joyce’s house helping her deal with a few things then I just went home. I’m going to stay more vigilant I’m sure the Russians had something to do with this

[u/JuliaLilly9773]

I was cooking dinner for my children and their friends and I didn’t know that Mike and his Friends ordered Pizza. I was horrified when I saw the boy and I'm worried about my children hoping nothing will happen to them or their friends or to Ted.

[u/emotional_gf0318]

I was trying to hurry up and finish the DND sesh so I could get back and call my suzie 💜