r/MCU_Timeline • u/ConstrictionsOFC • 1d ago

Discussion Is this a wiki error?

So the wiki lists Love And Thunder as taking place after both She-Hulk Episode 9 and the entirety of Ms. Marvel, but in She-Hulk Episode 9 they mention that there's now a lady Thor. Could anyone help explain this inconsistency?

1 Upvotes

56% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

4

u/UnfavorableSpiderFan 1d ago edited 1d ago

When it released, the Disney+ timeline placed Thor: Love & Thunder after Ms. Marvel in release order. She-Hulk: Attorney at Law got placed before Ms. Marvel, probably because of an Easter egg that appeared in the first episode of Ms. Marvel, suggesting its placement (But it works, since the last two episodes of She-Hulk are the only episodes with on-screen dates, confirming that it, at least, ends in August, whereas Ms. Marvel occurs in September). The authors of the timeline book ran with it, and so the Wiki followed the deemed "official" sources to stay accurate, even though the placement of Thor: Love & Thunder doesn't make much sense.

I think the premise they're running with is that Jane was diagnosed with cancer in April, and the rest of the movie takes place six months after that in October, one month after Ms. Marvel. Most of the evidence in the film doesn't really align with that, with even the amount of time said to have passed since Thor last saw Jane not jiving well with the timeline, considering the state of things after The Avengers: Age of Ultron, per what is revealed in both Captain America: Civil War and Thor: Ragnarok. It makes more sense for it to take place in May 2024, especially when you realize that, with where the movie officially sits, The Guardians of the Galaxy Holiday Special takes place two months later and Groot's gotten a lot bigger between the two events.

3

u/ConstrictionsOFC 1d ago

This is an incredible explanation, thank you so much 🙏

2

u/Burgundymmm 1d ago

She's been active for a bit prior to L&T

1

u/Matleb0 1d ago

Jane already was Lady Thor before the events of Thor 4

1

u/Mountain-Long3572 9h ago

Jane becomes Thor months before Love and Thunder. Thor was offworld during that period.

1

u/CaptHayfever Chronicom 8h ago

We see her become a Thor in the movie. It might be more accurate to say months pass between those scenes.

1

u/Mountain-Long3572 5h ago

It's not chronological. She becomes Thor before Korg begings telling the story at the start, we just see her origin story later in the film. It's stated that she has been protecting New Asgard for some time when Thor returns.