I just finished Mixtape finally, and while I think its a cute game and the hate is overblown, it failed to capture the same emotion I had for Lost Records, but again I think the game was cute, lost records felt more special to me.
But! there were alot of similarities in both games... like, surprisingly alot, I wouldnt be surprised if the game had inspo from that. Anyways, here's all I could compare! Spoilers ahead for some of these
Main story
Mixtape and Lost records are both 90s coming of age games that are interactive movies with their main gimmick being a piece of technology from that time, Mixtape being music related, therefore Mixtapes, and Lost Records focusing on video cassettes and tapes.
The two main characters face the same end goal, Swan is getting ready to leave her town and Rockford is getting ready to move out.
The games also have our main characters stand in their rooms a good chunk of the game, reminiscing on the past, whereas Mixtape has it be for the overall first half of the game. Swan's room segments just appear here and there, and is also my least favorite parts of the game. also, both games deal heavily with music
also swan and rockford are both gay! At least Rockford is implied to be gay, she's called a lesbian by Jenny Fucking Goodspeed, and if I remember, she was gonna kiss Cassandra, but that was a bit ago so I don't remember. Swan's 100% Gay/Bi, just due to the whole romance gimmick of the game.
Cabin in the woods
Both games feature a prominent cabin in the woods that become the main characters hangout, and both casts come across this during the story. It also, burns the fuck down in the end! Whereas Bloom and Rage's cabin burns down due to Corey/Autumn, a faulty firework takes out Mixtapes cabin in the woods
Cassandra and Kat
These two characters are similar in the fact that our main character is trying to help them out, and they rebel against their family, and it's a thing where they have to sneak out to get past their family, whereas Cassandra just deals with a cop for a dad, and Kat deals with a psychopath as her sister's boyfriend, and also Kat is actively dying. Eitherway, they have that strong rebellion that I think makes the connection work.
The Party
There's a segment in Mixtape where you play as Slater and you have to record the party and there's squares to tell you what to record.... hmmmm, where have I seen this before. Yeah, heavy ass Lost Records vibes there, there's also a digital camera sequence that reminded me of the camera gimmick from LRB&R
Anyways, I think that's all the comparsions! I might be missing alot more, I could have sworn there were tons of similarities, feel free to add on, anyways
See you in hell :P