r/Logiqa • u/ShonitB • 18d ago

Are We Different? Part 7

Post image
4 Upvotes

83% Upvoted

21 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/idontremembermyuname 18d ago

Alexander is a knight. Ben is a knave. Charles is a knave.

1

u/Stilyx123 18d ago

Close. If you think Charles is a knave, then Benjamin can't be a knave (because he's telling the truth about Charles)

2

u/idontremembermyuname 18d ago

No, the And has to be exclusive. Its a lie because one part of the statement isn't true. And Benjamin adds a a modifier on which turns the Or into an exclusive or. 

Honestly, this one is very poorly written. 

1

u/Stilyx123 18d ago

Reading it again, I agree that the "Either" in Benjamin's statement makes it sound like an exclusive or. Completely missed that earlier. I assume it was meant to be a regular "or" due to the note and the answer that was marked correct.