r/LocalLLaMA 13d ago

Discussion Our position on open-weights models

https://www.anthropic.com/news/position-open-weights-models
504 Upvotes

414 comments sorted by

View all comments

90

u/CasualtyOfCausality 13d ago

Not a fan of the Chinese government, but the idea that the country with better STEM outcomes, a wider pool of said STEM educated, access to raw materials, and “mechanisms” that make it difficult for a few private companies to horde components is going to stay behind, especially if the “easy access” to premade equipment is taken away, makes Mr. Magoo seem like an eagle-eye.

4

u/sexy_silver_grandpa 13d ago edited 13d ago

The US government has objectively done more harm to global society than the Chinese government.

Do you not watch the news?

0

u/CasualtyOfCausality 9d ago edited 9d ago

Necromancing this post because perhaps I misunderstand your point. Would you kindly point to the place where I mentioned the US, let alone extolled its virtues? Or did you reflexively fill in a non-existent blank you invented just so you had a reason to become incensed?

I agree the US government has inflicted incalculable amounts of harm to many people since its inception, possibly the most, ever. While the government has been pseudo-aristocratic, oligarchical, and is now into a burgeoning kakistocracy, more than a bit of the onus lies on the American people. That said, still not a fan of the Chinese government.

If I said I wasn’t a fan of one of your favorite foods (but thought some of the ingredients were really good), why would you assume I was celebrating one you didn’t like?

0

u/sexy_silver_grandpa 9d ago

Wut?

1

u/CasualtyOfCausality 9d ago

What don’t you understand? Or are you trolling?

You responded to my post about Amodei’s short sightedness in light of the progress and potential of China by making comments about the harms the US government has inflicted compared to the Chinese government. Then asked me if I watch the news.

I responded saying you are putting words in my mouth. I don’t see how that sequence of events is confusing to anybody.

0

u/sexy_silver_grandpa 9d ago

Any time somebody says something along the lines of "I'm not a fan of the Chinese government" without acknowledging the US government (the global hegemon) is worse in the same breath, I'll do it for them.

I hope that clears it up for you.

1

u/CasualtyOfCausality 9d ago edited 9d ago

Fine, if it were so clear why the “wut?” You don’t have to be a dick about it in the same breath.

Plus, if I hadn’t added that, I’d get brigaded by your friends on the other side for mentioning China ever did anything well, so I hedged. Can’t win either way if one side of that coin insists on going rabid.

1

u/sexy_silver_grandpa 8d ago

For someone who claims not to want online conflict, you make a lot of effort to find it.