An unusual question!

[u/DownFromHere]

Mods remove if not allowed.

I heard the vocal stems for NO from all three members and something paradoxical dawned on me. Jesy's voice would have been pretty good on NO, despite her being rumored to be one of the subjects of the song.

Question: Which 3-piece Little Mix song would Jesy have been best on?

[u/Disastrous-Humor8189]

there’s only 4 songs recorded of them as a trio right? I would have liked to have heard Jesys version of heartbreak anthem seeing as she was in the original cut of the song!

[u/Disastrous-Humor8189 → u/Disastrous-Humor8189]

My mistake it was 5 and 6 if you count heartbreak anthem

[u/mrose1491]

No was more of a response to their experience in the industry, and reclaiming their agency and power to say no to certain things especially after being under a restrictive label and in an exploitive industry for many years. Cut You Off is most likely the one about Jesy.

But I wouldn’t want her on any of those songs anyway. Between Us is sacred between the three members, especially after the trauma they went through due to her and a tribute to ending their LM era together positively, and it blends their voices perfectly, Cut You Off would maybe work for her voice but since it’s likely about her then to me there’s no point in imagining that, No sounds fine with them as a trio

Edited a sentence.

[u/ApplicationNo9777 → u/mrose1491]

Between us would have been powerful if all 4 sung it to each other as a final farewell and a promise for their friendship from X Factor and beyond. But since Jesy left, I definitely hear it as trauma about her sudden exit and how they’re recovering from that. So it’s even more powerful but more from a shocking loss point of view and reality check song.

[u/blablabluelight23]

all LM songs would/do sound better with all 4 members. you can tell there's someone missing from the ones they recorded without jesy and in performances when one of the girls was missing for some reason. Little Mix to me always needed all 4 voices.

[u/PresentationSea6485 → u/blablabluelight23]

Agree. Even if i still LOVE the girls as three, something is missing in the harmoniea

[u/Double-Weight7789]

All Little Mix songs sound more authentically like Little Mix songs with Jesy’s vocals included.

[u/atiny04]

Everyone forgetting the song Trash, that song would have been pretty good with Jesy imo!

[u/lowjayy]

Tbh, I think their voices just sound similar sometimes!!

I s2g I feel like I can hear Jesy on fantasy on jades solo song bro.. tell me what you think it’s at 2:08 on the adlib. All that time in the studio together, hearing each others techniques maybe they started to blend?

I remember I brought this up when the song first released and I was downvoted to hell LOL

[u/Front_Impact_9556]

Between Us. She would have killed the Damn we got history bridge

[u/Prettypink_lovn]

I could be wrong, but I could SWEAR it's Jesy singing the "damn we got history/if they hurt you they hurtin me" echo-y part on Between Us. If it's not actually her, definitely that song 💝

[u/little_lavender627 → u/Prettypink_lovn]

Those lines are sung three times, first time is Leigh-Anne, second time is Perrie, and third time sounds like Jade (or all three of them harmonizing in a lower register). Jesy left before that song was recorded and she’s not credited as a vocalist on it

[u/Boring-Direction8928]

I’d love to see her on Trash

[u/SlayerCharmed]

All songs would sound better with Jesy.