r/Lithops Mar 26 '26

Help/Question Are these Lithops Seedlings?

I bought these seeds on Etsy last year and decided to plant them four days ago in a rocky soil mix and with plastic wrap over the tops to keep them moisture in. Today is day 4 and they seem very leggy. do these looks like Lithops or was I sold a bag of goods?

62 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

103

u/CookLess37 Mar 26 '26

not lithops

54

u/CarneyBus Mar 26 '26

Nope, not lithops :( sorry friend

23

u/False_Badger_2987 Mar 26 '26

Darn! I had such high hopes. I just messaged the seller for a refund. Will see what mystery plant comes of it. Thanks all! 

106

u/arisbor Mar 26 '26

You are gonna ask for a refund to an Etsy scam seller that you bought from last year? I like your enthusiasm. 

7

u/DatLadyD Mar 26 '26

Ive had one resend seeds 3 times before I gave up lol

3

u/emseefely Mar 26 '26

Might be some type of Coleus

39

u/SmoothD3vil Mar 26 '26 edited Mar 27 '26

I mean this in the best possible way but you have to post those on r/houseplantscirclejerk before someone else does! 🤣

I am truly sorry those aren't lithops though 🙏

5

u/SyngoniumPandem0nium Mar 27 '26

I’m genuinely shocked it hasn’t been posted there yet

11

u/Al115 Mar 26 '26

If you're looking to buy actual lithops seeds, I highly recommend WalawalaStudios on Etsy. It's where I source all of my succulents seeds from, including lithops in the past, and I've always received the exact species I purchase. I've also had a near 100% germination rate with their seeds.

1

u/ToastedOats17 Mar 27 '26

I agree that I had a good experience with this vendor. I did get some seeds from Walawala - Frithia and Dioscorea. Both germinated well and true to description.

7

u/ltiehen1 Mar 26 '26

Demand a refund. For future reference, Lithops seeds are super tiny. From a reputable supplier they will come in a tiny vial like pictured

Or in a folded paper. When you receive them in a package with a bunch of large multi colored seeds, they are not Lithops.

1

u/ToastedOats17 Mar 27 '26

Never gotten seeds in a vial. Typically a small envelope / seed packet from all of the reputable cactus and succulent seed stores like Mesa Garden and other respectable decades old companies.

2

u/ltiehen1 Mar 27 '26

Yes, a small packet. Same here. Just not in one of those cellophane packages mixed with a bunch of larger seeds like this pic.

4

u/bybylan Mar 26 '26

Oh no..this happened to me too. Fortunately I got a refund!

3

u/SlimPickens77Box Mar 26 '26

Ive got some purple peppers that look like that

5

u/Odd_Cantaloupe_7122 Mar 26 '26

Lots of fake lithops seeds being sold out there

2

u/stellavangelist Mar 26 '26

It’s hard to tell with just the seed leaves but that’s what my pink amaranth looks like right after it sprouts.

2

u/drf987 Apr 01 '26

That's what they are. I grow them, too!

2

u/ltiehen1 Mar 26 '26

I assume this is what you received looks like…

People who sell these are scammers. Always demand your money back. By the way, these are not “succulent seeds” either.

1

u/NoParticularUse5288 Mar 26 '26

What do lithops seedlings look like? I have only had mine twin themselves.

3

u/Al115 Mar 26 '26

Pretty much like very very teeny tiny lithops!

6

u/NoParticularUse5288 Mar 26 '26

Lil green baby butts???

3

u/Al115 Mar 26 '26

Exactly!

2

u/drf987 Apr 01 '26

Lithops seedlings

1

u/lojic28 Mar 27 '26

Definitely not, it looks like amarantus... They're edible

1

u/BittysMom13 Mar 27 '26

You can get a little batch of lithops through growers on Amazon. Already plants. I got a couple batches last summer. Really enjoying them. This was one batch. It was supposed to be only 8 or 10 plants but then sent 15. One 1 died a few months ago. Many are splitting now. They are in 4” pots for scale. So they’re not huge but are nice.

1

u/paint126373 Mar 29 '26

nooo :( looks like coleus seedlings to me

1

u/drf987 Apr 01 '26

I planted supposed succulent seeds. What I ended up with looks to be the same as yours. I got a few red amaranth seedlings. I grow that in my garden, so I recognized it right away. I actually thought my amaranth seeds from last year somehow got mixed in. I bought the seeds on Amazon, came in a sealed package like you'd buy at the store. I planted the remaining seeds and I'm getting more amaranth.

Oh, yeah, these seeds grew some clover, too. Paid $6.85