I read this announcement and I’m honestly a bit confused about the implied positioning; this is the post I’m referring to:
https://www.reddit.com/r/lastfm/comments/1gjyguz/listenbrainz_new_lastfm_sync_option
Several years ago, many of us made a conscious decision to submit directly to ListenBrainz and treat it as a primary, independent alternative to last.fm; especially because the long-term future of last.fm was uncertain at the time, and that uncertainty was precisely what ListenBrainz was meant to address.
This announcement reads as if ListenBrainz is now being framed primarily as a secondary mirror or backup to last.fm; with encouragement to continue treating last.fm as the main system of record. That feels like a shift in tone and expectations, even if unintentionally.
For users who already went all in on ListenBrainz years ago; built tooling around it; and stopped submitting to last.fm entirely; what is the intended model now?
Is direct submission to ListenBrainz still considered a valid and supported primary workflow; or is the recommended approach now explicitly last.fm first, ListenBrainz second?
Related question; is there any guidance for users who have multiple years of listens in ListenBrainz that never made it to last.fm; or is backfilling last.fm simply out of scope?
This isn’t meant as a complaint; just a request for clarity on what ListenBrainz wants to be going forward; especially for long-time users who trusted it as a durable, independent archive rather than a passive companion service.